Assurance of Salvation: Free Study Tests
Test What You Learned from the Videos
Test what you learned from these videos on the Assurance of Salvation page. Tests are offered only for videos whose words are in the public domain. The other videos on that page do not have tests because their content is protected by copyright.
How to take a test:
- Open a test below and play its video. The questions follow the order of the video.
- When you hear an answer, pause the video and write the answer down.
- The time after each question, such as (about 2:15), shows where in the video to listen.
- Questions marked ★ are the key questions. If you are new to Bible study, start with those and come back for the rest later.
- You don't have to finish a test in one sitting. A few questions a day is fine.
- Answer in your own words. Where a question asks for a verse, the reference is enough (quote it if you can).
- It's open book. Watch the video as many times as you like.
- When you finish, open the answer key under the test to check your answers.
- The self-examination questions at the end of each test have no answer key. They are for honest reflection and prayer.
Bible translation: Verses in the answer keys are quoted from the Berean Standard Bible (BSB). Quoting from another faithful translation, such as the KJV, NKJV, ESV, NASB or CSB, is also acceptable. Paraphrases are not. Read the BSB free online at Bible Hub: biblehub.com/bsb
Test: "Religious Affections, Part 1" by Jonathan Edwards (10h:29m:19s)
Watch the video (opens in a new tab)
- In the Introduction, what question does Edwards say is of greater importance to mankind than any other? (about 0:05)
- Edwards says it is hard, but necessary, to do two things at the same time about the recent revival. What are they? (about 2:35)
- Name two earlier times of revival that Edwards says were also followed by much false religion or falling away. (about 3:55)
- What picture from nature does Edwards use to show that many who look religious in a time of revival do not last? (about 6:05)
- Name three harms Edwards says counterfeit religion does when it is not distinguished from true religion. (about 7:45)
- According to Edwards, by what means has the devil gained his greatest advantage against the cause and kingdom of Christ - even more than by persecution? (about 8:15)
- When religion revives and its friends are busy opposing open enemies, how does Edwards say the devil attacks them? (about 11:40)
- How does the aim of this book differ from Edwards' earlier writing on the marks of a work of the Spirit? (about 16:30)
- ★ What verse is Edwards' text for the whole treatise? Give the reference and quote it. (about 17:35)
- Name the three benefits that trials bring to true religion. (about 18:30)
- What two exercises of true religion does the apostle point out in the persecuted Christians he wrote to? (about 22:00)
- ★ State Edwards' main doctrine in one sentence. (about 25:45)
- ★ How does Edwards define the affections? (about 27:05)
- What two faculties has God given the soul? What other names are given to the second one? (about 27:10)
- Is the body or the mind the proper seat of the affections? Explain Edwards' answer. (about 33:20)
- How does Edwards distinguish an affection from a passion? (about 34:35)
- Give one Scripture Edwards uses to show that God requires us to be fervent and wholehearted in religion. (about 37:25)
- Edwards contrasts the power of godliness with its form. What verse does he use, and where does the power of true religion first appear? (about 39:45)
- Why does Edwards call the affections the spring of men's actions, and what does this show about true religion? (about 42:05)
- What does Edwards boldly assert about anyone who was ever changed by something religious that he read, heard, or saw? (about 46:45)
- Name at least five affections in which Scripture places true religion. (about 48:00)
- ★ Which affection does Edwards call the chief of the affections and the fountain of all the others? Give a supporting verse. (about 1:02:20)
- Name at least two people whose example Edwards gives to show that the religion of the most eminent saints was full of holy affections. (about 1:07:05)
- Give three ways the Lord Jesus showed holy affections, according to Edwards. (about 1:19:55)
- What does Edwards say the religion of heaven consists of, and what does that tell us about true religion on earth? (about 1:22:40)
- Edwards says that to know the nature of true gold, you must view it refined, not in the ore. How does he apply this to true religion? (about 1:27:40)
- Why did God appoint prayer, singing praises, the sacraments, and preaching? (about 1:29:30)
- What does Scripture call a heart without holy affection, and how does Edwards describe it? (about 1:36:40)
- What is a "tender heart" according to Edwards, and whom does he give as an example? (about 1:37:00)
- Edwards says the degree of a person's religion is not always in proportion to how strongly he feels at the moment. By what is it better judged? (about 1:41:05)
- In his inferences, what two opposite errors about religious affections does Edwards warn against? (about 1:42:00)
- Complete Edwards' statement: "A man's having much affection does not prove that he has any true religion; but if he has no affection, ..." Then explain what "heat without light" and "light without heat" mean. (about 1:46:20)
- Since true religion lies much in the affections, what kind of means does Edwards say are to be desired - and with what condition? (about 1:49:25)
- According to Edwards, what should we be ashamed of when we compare how we respond to worldly things and to the things of God? (about 1:51:35)
- Why, according to Edwards, are many people unmoved by the great things they hear from God's Word? (about 1:52:55)
- ★ What is the purpose of the section on things that are "no certain signs"? (about 1:59:00)
- Is it a sure sign of grace that religious affections are raised very high? Give one Bible example Edwards uses. (about 1:59:45)
- Do great effects on the body prove that religious affections are gracious - or prove that they are false? (about 2:12:55)
- Give two Bible examples Edwards uses to show that a sight of God's glory can overcome the body. (about 2:20:40)
- Is being fluent, fervent, and abundant in talking about religion a sure sign of grace? Why or why not? (about 2:23:20)
- Why does Edwards say false affections, if equally strong, are more forward to show themselves than true ones? (about 2:23:50)
- What two pictures does Edwards use for a person who is overfull of talk about his own experiences? Give one verse that goes with them. (about 2:28:30)
- Why is it not a sure sign that affections came on a person without his own effort or contrivance? (about 2:29:30)
- To show that God makes His power visible when He saves, so that no one may boast, what Old Testament deliverances does Edwards point to? Name two. (about 2:35:05)
- Is it a sure sign of grace when texts of Scripture come suddenly and remarkably to mind? What example shows this? (about 2:41:55)
- Can there be an appearance of love, and many kinds of religious affections together, in someone who has no saving grace? (about 2:50:25)
- Edwards says the more excellent a thing is, the more counterfeits it has. What examples does he give, and which two graces does he say are most often counterfeited? (about 2:51:45)
- Name three people in Scripture whose sorrow for sin, gratitude, zeal, or longing Edwards gives as counterfeits of true grace. (about 2:57:20)
- Edwards imagines a terrified sinner who is deceived by a vision or voice that he takes to be Christ. What false affections follow, and what picture does Edwards use to show how one false love produces many false affections? (about 3:00:20)
- What do the dreams of Pharaoh's chief cupbearer and chief baker illustrate? (about 3:06:40)
- Is it a sure sign when comforts and joys follow awakenings and convictions in a certain order? Why not? (about 3:07:20)
- Give two Bible examples Edwards uses to show that God often brings people into distress before He gives them comfort. (about 3:09:35)
- How does Edwards distinguish terror from true conviction of conscience? (about 3:21:05)
- Why does Edwards say Satan can imitate the order of the Spirit's work even more easily than the works themselves? (about 3:26:40)
- Should we judge a conversion by the steps and method of the Spirit's work, or by something else? Explain, and give a verse. (about 3:30:35)
- Is spending much time in religion, and zeal for outward duties of worship, a sure sign of grace? (about 3:40:10)
- Whom did Edwards once live next door to for many months, and what point did this prove? (about 3:47:05)
- Is it a sure sign that people praise and glorify God much with their mouths? Give an example. (about 3:47:45)
- ★ Does a strong confidence that one's experiences are from God, and that one is in a good state, prove that it is so? Explain. (about 3:53:45)
- Edwards gives reasons why a hypocrite with false confidence seldom doubts his state. Name two. (about 4:03:15)
- What are "legal" and "evangelical" hypocrites, and which does Edwards (following Thomas Shepard) say is worse? (about 4:10:30)
- Some say a Christian should "live by faith, not by sight" and "trust God in the dark" even when he is in a dead, carnal frame. What does Edwards say is wrong with this teaching as many understand it? (about 4:15:10)
- Why does Edwards say it is right, not wrong, for a Christian in a dead, carnal frame to doubt his state? What picture does he use for love and fear? Give the verse. (about 4:28:15)
- According to Edwards, assurance is obtained not so much by self-examination as by what? Give Paul's example. (about 4:30:20)
- Can godly people infallibly judge another person's spiritual state by how moving and pleasing that person's account of his experiences is? Give a supporting verse. (about 4:40:15)
- When we judge others' spiritual state, what lesson does Edwards draw from spring blossoms, from the wheat and the tares (Matthew 13:26), and from what Peter said about Silvanus? (about 4:41:55)
- At the start of the section on distinguishing signs, Edwards says what the signs are NOT meant to do. Name two of these limits. (about 4:56:25)
- What two "defects" make it impossible for a saint who is very low in grace, or in a bad frame, to know his good state for certain? (about 4:59:15)
- ★ First sign: from what kind of influences do truly gracious affections arise? (about 5:08:30)
- How does the Holy Spirit's work in a true saint differ from His influence on a natural (unconverted) man? Give a supporting verse. (about 5:22:00)
- Edwards explains the "new spiritual sense" given in regeneration by comparing it to tasting honey. Explain the comparison. Is this new sense a new faculty? (about 5:36:35)
- Why did Balaam's vision of the Star out of Jacob not make him a spiritual man? (about 5:39:25)
- What does Edwards say about impressions on the imagination, such as visions, voices, or a mental image of Christ on the cross? (about 5:39:45)
- How does Edwards explain the witness of the Spirit in Romans 8:16? What is it NOT, and what IS it? (about 5:56:00)
- What does Edwards say the "seal of the Spirit" really is? What is it compared to, and what else is it called? (about 6:38:05)
- ★ Second sign: what is the first objective ground (foundation) of gracious affections? (about 7:00:00)
- Satan asked, "Does Job fear God for nothing?" (Job 1:9). What does Edwards learn from this about love to God? (about 7:07:20)
- How does gracious gratitude differ from the natural gratitude that even wicked men (and animals) can have? Give two differences. (about 7:10:15)
- According to the second sign, how does a hypocrite's love and joy differ from a true saint's? (about 7:19:40)
- Edwards answers the objection from 1 John 4:19, "We love because He first loved us." Name one way, as Edwards explains it, that God's love to us is the ground of our love to Him. (about 7:26:00)
- What does Edwards say is the true meaning of "living upon experiences," and how is it different from using experiences as evidence? (about 7:33:45)
- Third sign: gracious affections are founded on the loveliness of what? (about 7:39:00)
- Explain the difference between God's moral attributes and His natural attributes. Which can devils and the wicked see, and which can they not? (about 7:43:20)
- Why does Edwards say a sight of God's awful greatness alone cannot change a person's heart, but the first glimpse of His holy beauty can? (about 8:08:20)
- Fourth sign: from what do gracious affections arise? What short phrase does Edwards use to describe affections without it? (about 8:17:50)
- Name two things that, according to Edwards, spiritual understanding is NOT. (about 8:30:55)
- How does the Holy Spirit lead God's children in their conduct, according to Edwards? Give one of his illustrations. (about 8:56:55)
- What is the difference between finding a new meaning in Scripture and truly understanding Scripture spiritually? Give the verse Edwards uses. (about 8:59:25)
- Name two groups in church history whose false religion, Edwards says, consisted in visions, raptures, and supposed revelations. (about 9:20:00)
- What Bible story does Edwards use to show how this "bastard religion," mingled with a true revival, can destroy it? (about 9:21:20)
- What does Edwards call the imagination, and why? (about 9:22:45)
- Fifth sign: what accompanies truly gracious affections? (about 9:31:00)
- Why does Edwards say a belief in Christianity that comes only from education is no better than a Muslim's belief in Islam? (about 9:42:05)
- Name two people (or groups) in Scripture who believed something true about Jesus without having saving grace. (about 9:43:40)
- In the fifth sign, Edwards explains two indirect ways a sight of divine glory helps a person believe the gospel. What are they? (about 9:51:30)
- How can an unlearned person have a reasonable conviction that the gospel is true without studying historical arguments? Give a supporting verse. (about 10:06:30)
- Why are the true martyrs called "witnesses"? Give a supporting verse. (about 10:12:30)
- Edwards says the gospel "does not go abroad begging for its evidence." What does he mean, and does he reject outward arguments for Christianity? (about 10:17:20)
- Why can't lying wonders, or Satan's dealings with witches, produce a saving conviction of the truth? Give a supporting verse. (about 10:25:45)
- Edwards says a natural man who thinks hell belongs to him will hardly believe hell exists. What happens when he becomes persuaded that hell is only for others, and what does this show? (about 10:26:50)
Self-examination (for reflection and prayer):
- Do my affections toward God rise mainly from seeing His holiness and excellence, or mainly from what I think He will do for me?
- Am I more easily moved by worldly things (sports, money, entertainment, pleasures) than by Christ's dying love? What does that say about my heart?
- Which of the "no certain signs" (strong feelings, much talk, Scripture coming to mind, confidence, others' approval) have I been leaning on for assurance?
- Do I rejoice more in God Himself, or in my own experiences and feelings about Him?
- Is my religion only a form, or does it have power in my heart and in the way I live?
Show answer key
- What are the distinguishing qualifications of those who are in favor with God and entitled to His eternal rewards? In other words: what is the nature of true religion, and what are the distinguishing marks of the virtue and holiness God accepts?
- To be a hearty, zealous friend of what has been good and glorious in it (and to rejoice in it), and at the same time to see the evil of what has been bad in it and earnestly oppose that. He says we will never be in the way of truth, or advance Christ's kingdom, until we do both.
- Any two: the reformation in Josiah's day (Jeremiah 3:10); the ministry of John the Baptist, when many rejoiced in his light only for a season (John 5:35); the crowds that followed Christ (many called, few chosen; stony and thorny ground); the apostles' days; the Protestant Reformation; the recent revival in New England.
- Fruit trees in spring: there are many fair, beautiful blossoms and a promising show of young fruit, but many soon fall off and never come to maturity.
- Any three: it deceives multitudes about the state of their souls; it makes some of the vilest hypocrites confident of their eminent holiness; it wounds and damps religion in true saints; it strengthens the open enemies of religion; it leads people to sin under a notion of serving God; it makes friends of religion do the work of enemies; it scatters the flock and drives people to extremes on either side; it opens the door to doubt, heresy, infidelity, and atheism.
- By the mixture of counterfeit religion with true religion, when the two are not discerned and distinguished. Edwards says this has hurt the church more than all the persecutions of Jews, heathens, and the Church of Rome.
- He comes from behind, unseen, and gives a fatal stab - he strikes at his leisure where they are not on guard, by mixing counterfeit religion with the true.
- The earlier work showed the marks of a work of the Spirit, including both His common and His saving operations. This book shows the nature and signs of the Spirit's gracious (saving) operations, distinguishing them from everything that is not saving.
- ★ 1 Peter 1:8: "Though you have not seen Him, you love Him; and though you do not see Him now, you believe in Him and rejoice with an inexpressible and glorious joy" (1 Peter 1:8, BSB).
- (1) They manifest its truth - they show whether it is true religion, as gold is tried in the fire. (2) They make its genuine beauty and loveliness appear. (3) They purify and increase it, purging away what is false, as fire purges gold of its dross.
- (1) Love to Christ, whom they had not seen. (2) Joy in Christ, which comes by faith and is inexpressible and full of glory.
- ★ True religion, in great part, consists in holy affections.
- ★ The affections are the more vigorous and sensible (strongly felt) exercises of the inclination and will of the soul.
- (1) The understanding - by which the soul perceives, views, and judges things. (2) The inclination - which, as it governs actions, is called the will, and the mind with regard to its exercises is often called the heart.
- The mind (soul) only. The motions of the body that go along with strong affections are only effects or companions of them, not part of them. A spirit without a body can love, hate, rejoice, grieve, hope, or fear just as one united to a body.
- "Affection" is the broader word: it covers all vigorous, lively actings of the will. A "passion" is more sudden, has more violent effects on the body, and leaves the mind more overpowered and less in its own command.
- Any one: "Do not let your zeal subside; keep your spiritual fervor, serving the Lord" (Romans 12:11, BSB); Deuteronomy 6:5 (love the Lord with all your heart, soul, and strength); Deuteronomy 10:12; or "And the LORD your God will circumcise your hearts and the hearts of your descendants, and you will love Him with all your heart and with all your soul, so that you may live" (Deuteronomy 30:6, BSB).
- "Having a form of godliness but denying its power" (2 Timothy 3:5, BSB). The power of true religion appears first in its inward exercises in the heart, which is its principal and original seat; outward appearances alone are only the form.
- Man is inactive unless moved by some affection - love, hatred, desire, hope, fear, and so on. Take away all affections and the world would be motionless and dead. Since true religion is practical (it moves us to act), it must consist very much in the affections.
- That no one was ever considerably changed in mind or conduct by anything religious he read, heard, or saw unless his affections were moved. People hear the Word again and again without change because they are not affected by it.
- Any five: fear (of God), hope, love, hatred (of sin), desire / longing, joy, sorrow / godly sorrow / a broken heart, gratitude / thankfulness, compassion / mercy, zeal.
- ★ Love. Supporting verses (any one): the two great commandments - love God with all your heart, and your neighbor as yourself (Matthew 22:37-40); 1 Corinthians 13 (without love, all else is nothing); "Love does no wrong to its neighbor. Therefore love is the fulfillment of the law" (Romans 13:10, BSB).
- Any two: David (the Psalms are full of holy affection); the apostle Paul; the apostle John; and above all the Lord Jesus Christ Himself, who had a most tender and affectionate heart (for example, He wept over Jerusalem and was moved with zeal and compassion).
- Any three: zeal for His Father's house (John 2:17); anger and grief at the hardness of men's hearts (Mark 3:5); weeping over Jerusalem (Luke 19:41-42); longing to gather Jerusalem's children as a hen gathers her chicks (Luke 13:34); earnest desire to eat the Passover with His disciples (Luke 22:15); compassion on the crowds; weeping with Mary and Martha (John 11); the tender farewell discourse and prayer (John 13-17); His love in Gethsemane, which overcame His fear and sorrow.
- The religion of heaven consists chiefly in holy and mighty love and joy, and in expressing them in praise. Since true religion on earth is of the same nature as the religion of heaven, it too consists very much in holy affections.
- To learn what true religion is, we must look where it is found pure and perfect - in heaven - and there it consists chiefly in holy love, joy, and praise. True saints belong to heaven; their grace is "the dawn of glory."
- Not to inform God, but to affect our own hearts - they are means suited to stir up holy affections in us.
- Hardness of heart. A hard heart is an unaffected heart - one not easily moved by holy, virtuous affections, like a stone. Scripture treats it as great sin.
- A heart easily impressed and moved with holy affections by what ought to affect it. Example: King Josiah, whose heart was tender, and who humbled himself and wept when he heard God's Word (2 Kings 22:19). We must become like little children in this way.
- By the fixedness and strength of the habit (settled disposition) that shows itself in holy affection - not by the degree of present emotion, which may be mixed with natural feeling and affected by the body.
- (1) Discarding all religious affections, as if there were nothing solid or substantial in them. (2) Approving all religious affections without distinguishing true from false. Both extremes are wrong.
- "...it proves that he has no true religion." Heat without light is a warm heart with no true understanding; light without heat is a head full of notions with a cold, unaffected heart. Neither is anything divine.
- Books, preaching, prayer, and singing that tend to move the affections deeply - provided the things of religion are treated according to their true nature, so as to give right apprehensions of them. Means that merely stir up passions without true understanding do not benefit souls.
- That we are no more affected by the great things of God (His glory, Christ's dying love, heaven and hell) when we are so easily and strongly moved by worldly things of little worth.
- Because they are blind. If they truly understood such great and glorious things, it would be impossible for their hearts not to be strongly moved.
- ★ To show things that are no sign one way or the other - they neither prove that affections are truly gracious nor prove that they are not.
- No. High affections can be false. Example: Israel at the Red Sea - "Then they believed His promises and sang His praise. Yet they soon forgot His works" (Psalm 106:12-13, BSB); or the crowd that cried "Hosanna" and soon after cried "Crucify Him." But high affections do not prove religion false either.
- Neither. False and natural affections can also affect the body greatly, and true affections may as well. Bodily effects prove nothing either way.
- Any two: Daniel was left with no strength (Daniel 10:8); the apostle John fell at Christ's feet as though dead (Revelation 1:17); Habakkuk's body trembled (Habakkuk 3:16); the psalmist's flesh trembled for fear of God (Psalm 119:120), and his heart and flesh cried out for the living God (Psalm 84:2).
- No. Hypocrites can talk much and fervently about religion; a great deal of talk often comes more from false affection than true. But it does not prove the affections are false either.
- Because it is the nature of false religion to seek show and the notice of others, as it was with the Pharisees.
- A tree overfull of leaves seldom bears much fruit; and a cloud that comes with much wind seldom gives much rain. Verses (any one): Proverbs 25:14 (clouds and wind without rain); Jude 12 (clouds without water, carried along by the winds); 2 Peter 2:17.
- Because other causes besides saving grace can bring affections on a person without his own contrivance - Satan, and the common (non-saving) influences of the Spirit.
- Any two: Israel's deliverance from Egypt with a strong hand, after they had been brought to utter helplessness; Gideon's victory with a handful of men armed only with trumpets, torches, and clay jars; David's defeat of Goliath with a sling and a stone. (He adds the conversion of the Gentiles after all the philosophers had failed to reform the world.)
- No. Satan can bring Scripture to mind, as he did when he quoted Scripture to Christ in the wilderness (Matthew 4:6). The sudden or remarkable way a text comes to mind proves nothing about whether the affections are gracious.
- Yes. There are counterfeits of love (and of every grace), and false affections can come in many kinds together, as in the multitude that welcomed Christ into Jerusalem and soon turned against Him.
- More counterfeits are made of gold and silver than of iron and copper; of diamonds and rubies than of common stones; and of the best medicines. Love and humility are the graces most often counterfeited.
- Any three: Pharaoh, King Saul, and Ahab (sorrow for sin); Naaman the Syrian (gratitude after his healing); Jehu, and Saul of Tarsus before his conversion (zeal); Balaam (longing for the happy state of God's people, Numbers 23:10); the Samaritans who feared the Lord but served their own gods (2 Kings 17:33).
- Joy, love to the "Christ" he imagined, admiration, gratitude, much talk about his experience, a show of humility ("Why me?"), love for those who admire him, fierce zeal against those who doubt such things, separating from others, and eagerness to make converts to his party. Picture: love is a fountain with many channels - sweet water gives sweet streams, poisoned water gives poisoned streams; or a tree whose sap, good or poisonous, runs into all the branches, so the difference is found only by tasting the fruit.
- True and false experiences can look very much alike. The two dreams seemed alike, and the baker's hopes were raised by Joseph's good news for the cupbearer - but his dream ended the opposite way: he was lifted out of prison only to be hanged.
- Because Satan can counterfeit the order (terrors, then comfort), and God's Spirit is not tied to one fixed method that we can use as a test. The order of experiences proves nothing; what matters is the nature of the experiences.
- Any two: Israel shut in at the Red Sea before deliverance; the wilderness before Canaan (Deuteronomy 8:2); the woman who spent all she had on physicians (Luke 8:43-44); the Canaanite woman (Matthew 15:22-28); the disciples in the storm crying "Lord, save us" (Matthew 8:25); the servant who owed ten thousand talents; the prodigal son; Joseph's brothers; Abraham's horror of great darkness before God's promises (Genesis 15:12); Elijah's wind, earthquake, and fire before the still, small voice (1 Kings 19); Paul's "sentence of death" (2 Corinthians 1:9); John the Baptist preaching repentance before Christ came.
- Conviction of conscience by the Spirit is a conviction of the sinfulness of one's heart and life, and of the dreadfulness of sin against a holy, just, and majestic God. Terror can come without it - from frightful images the devil impresses (hell gaping, a drawn sword, a frowning face) or from a person's constitution and imagination - and some speak of their great sinfulness without seeing any particular sin.
- If Satan can make counterfeit A, B, and C, it is just as easy for him to put A first, B next, and C last. The nature of divine things is hard for him to imitate, but their order is easy. Only what Satan cannot do is a certain evidence of grace.
- By the nature of the fruits - the effect God has brought about in the soul - not by the method. The Spirit's way is often mysterious, like the wind (John 3:8) or the forming of a child in the womb (Ecclesiastes 11:5); Thomas Shepard said the first work can be like "a confused chaos." The clearest work is not where the order is clearest, but where the spiritual and divine nature of the work is clearest.
- No. Hypocrites can be very zealous in outward worship - for example, the people God rebuked in Isaiah 1 and Isaiah 58, who were busy with sacrifices, feasts, and fasts while their hearts were far from Him, and the Pharisees.
- A Jewish man who seemed the most devout person Edwards ever saw, spending much of his time - sometimes whole nights - in devotion at his window. It proves that much time spent in religious exercises is no sure sign of saving grace (as with the hermits, recluses, and Pharisees).
- No. The multitudes glorified God at Christ's miracles, and Israel sang His praise at the Red Sea, yet many of them did not truly believe or soon forgot Him.
- ★ No. Hypocrites can be very confident, like the Pharisee in the temple. In fact, false confidence is often stronger and more unshaken, because the hypocrite does not see his own corruption, while true saints may sometimes doubt. Confidence alone proves nothing.
- Any two: (1) he lacks the cautious spirit and dread of being deceived that true saints have; (2) he does not see his own blindness and the deceitfulness of his heart; (3) the devil does not attack his hope (it serves the devil), but he attacks the hope of true saints, as he did with Christ ("If You are the Son of God..."); (4) he does not see his own corruption, which a false hope covers up.
- Legal hypocrites trust in their outward morality and religion. Evangelical hypocrites are deceived by false discoveries and high feelings; they cry down works and talk much of free grace, yet make a righteousness of their own experiences. The evangelical hypocrites are the worse - the most confident and the hardest to undeceive.
- In Scripture, "faith, not sight" means trusting unseen, eternal things and God's promises when His providence looks dark - not holding a confident hope without any spiritual light while living in a dead, carnal frame, which is presumption. Faith is not believing that I am in a good state (if it were, the Pharisees had great faith); faith is what brings a person into a good state.
- Assurance cannot be kept alive when grace is not in exercise, any more than light can stay in a room when the candle is put out. God has ordered that love and fear rise and fall like the two scales of a balance: when love decays, fear rises to restrain from sin; when love is strong, it drives fear out. "There is no fear in love, but perfect love drives out fear" (1 John 4:18, BSB).
- By action - mortifying sin, growing in grace, and pressing forward. Paul gained assurance chiefly by "forgetting what is behind and straining toward what is ahead" (Philippians 3:13, BSB), and by not running aimlessly (1 Corinthians 9:26) - he gained assurance of winning more by running than by examining his pace. Peter likewise tells us to add virtue to our faith and so make our calling and election sure (2 Peter 1:5-10).
- No. God has not given us the ability to know infallibly the state of another's soul, and hypocrites can tell their experiences in very moving ways. "Man sees what is outward, but the LORD sees the heart" (1 Samuel 16:7, BSB).
- Blossoms that drop off look and smell as fair as those that bear fruit, so we must judge by the ripe fruit. Wheat and tares can hardly be told apart until the ear (the fruit) appears. Even Peter spoke of Silvanus only as one "whom I regard as a faithful brother" (1 Peter 5:12, BSB) - he did not claim to know another's heart. Judging hearts belongs to God; we judge the tree chiefly by its fruit.
- Any two: (1) They are not meant to let anyone distinguish with certainty true saints from hypocrites in others. (2) They are not meant to give certainty to saints of small grace or those in a cold, declining state. (3) They are not likely to convince hypocrites who are settled in false hope. Edwards adds that assurance is gained not so much by self-examination as by action - by mortifying sin and growing in grace.
- (1) A defect in the object: his grace is so small and so mixed with corruption that it cannot be clearly seen (like tiny embryos, or a star and a comet seen through cloud or smoke). (2) A defect in the eye: sin darkens his spiritual sight, like a disease of the eye, or a sick palate that makes everything taste bitter. Signs help him no more than rules for telling objects apart in the dark.
- ★ From influences and operations on the heart that are spiritual, supernatural, and divine.
- In true saints the Spirit dwells as a lasting, vital principle of a new nature, giving them a new spiritual sense of divine things. In natural men He only moves and assists their natural principles (common grace) without dwelling in them. "The natural man does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God. For they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually discerned" (1 Corinthians 2:14, BSB).
- Seeing and touching honey gives one kind of idea; tasting its sweetness gives an entirely different kind, which a person without the sense of taste cannot imagine. So the saint perceives in divine things something a natural man cannot conceive of at all. It is not a new faculty, but a new principle (foundation) laid in the soul for a new kind of exercise of the same understanding and will.
- Because God only impressed outward ideas on his natural senses and imagination (a common influence); He gave him no new spiritual sense. The Day Star never rose in Balaam's heart (Numbers 24:16-17).
- They are not spiritual in themselves. Satan can produce such impressions, and affections that arise from them are no proof of grace; they can even be very dangerous.
- It is NOT an immediate inner voice or sudden suggestion that one is a child of God. It IS the Spirit working in the heart as the Spirit of adoption - giving the holy, childlike love to God that casts out fear. "The Spirit Himself testifies with our spirit that we are God's children" (Romans 8:16, BSB).
- It is not a secret voice or suggestion, but a holy stamp - God's own image - impressed on the heart by the Spirit, like a seal pressed into wax (seals bore the owner's image and name; Song of Songs 8:6). It is also called the "earnest" (pledge, down payment) of the Spirit (2 Corinthians 1:22; Ephesians 1:13-14) - that is, grace itself, especially holy love, the beginning of glory.
- ★ The transcendently excellent and lovely nature of divine things as they are in themselves - not any relation they bear to self or self-interest.
- That a mercenary love to God - loving Him only for benefits received or hoped for - is worthless in God's sight. Even the devil knew it, and God allowed Job to be tried to show that his love was not of that kind. True love to God begins with God's own excellency.
- (1) Gracious gratitude flows from a love already in the heart for what God is in Himself; natural gratitude has no such foundation (as when Saul was moved to gratitude toward David yet remained his enemy, or a dog loves a kind master). (2) The saint is moved by God's goodness and free grace as part of the glory and beauty of God's nature, not only as it serves his own interest - God's kindness to him is like a mirror in which he sees that beauty.
- The hypocrite loves God first because he thinks God loves him or benefits him (self-love is the foundation), and he rejoices in himself and his own experiences. The true saint first loves God for His own excellency and beauty (and then also for His benefits), and rejoices in God Himself.
- Any one: (1) God gave His people a spirit of love to Him because He loved them from eternity; (2) God's love in redemption through Christ is one of the chief displays of His moral glory, and so a main reason to love Him; (3) God's love shown to a person in his conversion is a fit occasion for holy gratitude. The apostle's point is to magnify God's love in loving us when we did not love Him.
- Living upon experiences means making a righteousness of them - turning the eyes off God's glory and Christ's excellency to admire one's own attainments. Edwards says this is more abominable to God than gross immorality. Using one's experiences of grace as evidences of a saving interest in Christ is right and necessary.
- The moral excellency of divine things - that is, their holiness. Saints love God chiefly for the beauty of His holiness.
- Moral attributes belong to the goodness of God's heart and will - His righteousness, truth, faithfulness, and goodness - summed up in His holiness. Natural attributes make up His greatness - His power, knowledge, eternity, omnipresence, and awful majesty. Devils and the wicked see God's greatness and tremble (and all will see it at the judgment), but they cannot see the beauty of His holiness.
- A sight of God's greatness may overpower and terrify, but the enmity of the heart remains and the will stays unbending. The first glimpse of God's moral beauty melts and humbles the heart, weans it from the world, and draws it to God - as if with almighty power that nothing can withstand.
- From the mind being enlightened rightly and spiritually to understand divine things. Holy affections are not "heat without light."
- Any two: new doctrinal knowledge or new propositions; a new explanation of a passage; knowing the hidden meaning of types, parables, and allegories (a man could interpret them all without one beam of spiritual light - 1 Corinthians 13:2); having one's duty suggested directly to the mind (as Balaam had); giving a text a new meaning it never had - as when someone takes "Do not be afraid to go down to Egypt" (Genesis 46:3, BSB) to mean that God wants him to travel to a certain foreign land.
- By a holy, spiritual taste and disposition that relishes what is truly beautiful and holy and is repelled by what is not, so the saint discerns good and evil readily, without a long chain of reasoning (yet the taste itself must be tested by God's Word; Romans 12:2). Illustrations (any one): one sees a beautiful face at a glance; a trained musical ear hears true harmony without a mathematician's help; a healthy palate knows good food without a physician; a falling stone finds its way toward the center of the earth in an instant better than a mathematician could in a day; a good-natured man or a loving friend knows how to act kindly better than the ablest reasoner without such a heart. This is as far above "leading" by inner dictates as the stars are above a glowworm.
- Spiritual understanding sees what was always in the text but was hidden by blindness - it opens the eyes. Making a new meaning is the same as making new Scripture, adding to God's Word. "Open my eyes that I may see wondrous things from Your law" (Psalm 119:18, BSB).
- Any two: the ancient Pythagoreans; the Essenes; the Gnostics and Montanists; the monks, hermits, and recluses of the Church of Rome; the Anabaptists, Antinomians, and Familists after the Reformation (such as the followers of Thomas Muntzer and John of Leiden); the wild enthusiasts in England in Cromwell's day; the followers of Mrs. Hutchinson in New England; the French Prophets.
- Gideon's illegitimate son Abimelech, who killed his seventy true-born brothers except one who escaped (Judges 9:5). Ministers must therefore keep a strict watch, especially in a time of great awakening.
- The devil's grand lurking place - the very nest of foul and deceiving spirits. Satan seems able to reach the soul only through the body and the imagination (outward ideas), which is why visions, voices, and impressions are his favorite tools, and why melancholy people are especially open to his suggestions.
- A reasonable and spiritual conviction of the judgment of the reality and certainty of divine things.
- Because it rests on the same ground - what one's parents, neighbors, and nation believe - not on real evidence. The thing believed is true, but the belief itself is no better in kind, and neither are the affections that come from it.
- Any two: Judas, who thought Jesus was the Messiah yet was a devil all along; the many who believed in His name when they saw His miracles, but to whom Jesus did not entrust Himself (John 2:23-25); Simon the sorcerer, who believed yet was "poisoned by bitterness and captive to iniquity" (Acts 8:13, 23, BSB).
- (1) It removes the heart's prejudices and enmity against the gospel, so reason is open to the evidence (as Christ's miracles convinced the disciples but not the scribes and Pharisees). (2) It positively helps reason - it makes ideas lively and clear, like seeing the landscape in sunlight instead of dim starlight or twilight.
- By a spiritual sight of the divine glory in the gospel itself - the gospel carries its own evidence of its truth to the enlightened heart. "For God, who said, 'Let light shine out of darkness,' made His light shine in our hearts to give us the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ" (2 Corinthians 4:6, BSB).
- A witness testifies to what he has seen, not merely to what he thinks is likely. The martyrs had seen the divine glory of the gospel, so they could say that it IS divine. Verses (any one): John 3:11; John 1:34; "And we have seen and testify that the Father has sent His Son to be the Savior of the world" (1 John 4:14, BSB); Hebrews 12:1.
- The gospel has its highest and most proper evidence in itself - its divine glory. He does not reject outward arguments: they should be highly valued, because they can awaken unbelievers, confirm the faith of true saints, and help prepare the way for saving faith.
- They may convince people of some doctrines, such as the reality of an invisible world of spirits, but they give no sight of God's glory and their final tendency is to promote atheism. A bare belief of truths without a sight of their divine glory is not saving: "You believe that God is one. Good for you! Even the demons believe that - and shudder" (James 2:19, BSB).
- He easily believes in hell and cries out at others' foolishness for neglecting to escape it - and if confident heaven is his, he may seem strong in faith that heaven is real. It shows that a person's belief in religion may grow only because he thinks it serves his own interest, not from true conviction.
Test: "Religious Affections, Part 2" by Jonathan Edwards (06h:54m:33s)
Watch the video (opens in a new tab)
- ★ Part 2 begins with the sixth distinguishing sign. According to this sign, what are gracious affections attended with? (about 0:05)
- How does Edwards define evangelical humiliation? (about 0:10)
- Give two differences between legal humiliation and evangelical humiliation: who can have each one, and where each one comes from. (about 0:20)
- In legal humiliation, what do people see of God and of themselves? In evangelical humiliation, what do they see? (about 0:55)
- What does evangelical humiliation do to a person's heart and will that legal humiliation does not do? (about 3:00)
- In legal humiliation people are "forced to the ground." How does Edwards describe the way people come down before God in evangelical humiliation? (about 3:00)
- Edwards says legal humiliation can still be useful. How is it useful, and what does it lack? (about 3:25)
- Give a verse that shows God's favor toward the humble or contrite. (about 5:25)
- What two kinds of self-denial does Edwards describe? Which is harder, and which one can hypocrites seem to do? (about 11:25)
- What did Edwards say about the hermits and recluses who gave up the world's pleasures but not their own glory? What two word pictures did he use? (about 12:10)
- Name at least two ways spiritual pride shows itself in a person who professes religion. (about 13:15)
- How do hypocrites often try to show humility in their speech? How would they react if a minister privately told them the same things they say about themselves? (about 16:30)
- What is a "legal spirit," according to Edwards? How can a person who talks loudly against legal preaching still have one? (about 17:05)
- How does a truly humble saint view his own humility and his own grace? How does the hypocrite view his? (about 21:15)
- What two things did Edwards say will surely discover (expose) spiritual pride? (about 23:05)
- Give the verse Edwards uses to show that true humility considers others better than oneself. Give the reference and quote it. (about 25:25)
- Why does a saint with more grace see his own grace as smaller? What illustration of a hungry man did Edwards use? (about 32:20)
- Why does even the least sin outweigh the highest holiness a creature can have? (about 39:30)
- What do false "discoveries" often do with a person's remaining sin, and what does true spiritual light do with it? (about 43:30)
- What did Agur say about himself after a great view of God's glory (Proverbs 30:2-4)? What New Testament verse makes the same point about knowledge? (about 51:45)
- Someone might object that David said he had more understanding than all his teachers (Psalm 119:99-100). Give Edwards' two answers. (about 53:55)
- Explain Edwards' illustration of a great man washing another's feet versus a slave untying a prince's shoes. What does it show about the person who admires his own humility? (about 58:05)
- Why does a person who is truly under great conviction of sin not think his conviction is great? (about 1:03:05)
- Is true humility loud and showy? Give at least one Bible example or verse Edwards uses to show what humility looks like. (about 1:08:25)
- Edwards warns of a trap in self-examination. What thought should a person watch for after he says, "I am as proud as the devil"? (about 1:11:25)
- Being "poor in spirit," the humble Christian behaves like a poor man. Give at least three ways this shows in his behavior. (about 1:11:55)
- Give two Bible examples Edwards uses of believers showing honor and respect even to unbelievers or enemies. (about 1:17:05)
- What does Mary's broken alabaster box picture, according to Edwards? (about 1:18:45)
- ★ Seventh sign: what are gracious affections attended with? (about 1:20:20)
- Seventh sign: what verse does Edwards use to show that beholding the glory of the Lord changes a person? Whose power alone can change a person's nature? (about 1:21:00)
- What verse speaks of the new creation in Christ? Give the reference and quote it. (about 1:21:55)
- What happens to religious affections that leave a person's nature unchanged? What Bible picture describes such a person? (about 1:24:10)
- What did Edwards mean by his picture of a washed swine and a soiled dove? (about 1:24:10)
- Does true conversion completely root out a person's natural temper and sins? How does it affect the sins he was most inclined to? (about 1:24:30)
- What lesson does Edwards draw from King Saul sparing Agag, king of the Amalekites? (about 1:26:05)
- Some people say that when God departs from them they are no better than before, and they take this as proof their experience was from God. Why is this a mistake? Explain Edwards' picture of a glass in the sunbeams. (about 1:28:15)
- ★ Eighth sign: what spirit do truly gracious affections naturally produce and promote? (about 1:34:05)
- What two creatures does Edwards use to describe the spirit of true Christians, and why are they fitting? (about 1:34:05)
- Give a verse in which Jesus describes His own gentle and humble heart. Give the reference and quote it. (about 1:40:30)
- Name at least three qualities of little children that Edwards says picture the followers of the Lamb. (about 1:49:20)
- According to Edwards, in what does true Christian fortitude (courage and strength) chiefly consist? Give a supporting verse. (about 1:51:50)
- From what does true boldness for Christ arise, and how is it different from a bitter, fierce zeal? (about 1:52:35)
- How did Jesus show the greatest fortitude (courage) of all during His sufferings? What did He do when Peter used his sword? (about 1:56:15)
- What is a much better trial of a person's boldness for Christ than being forward to provoke opposers? (about 1:57:45)
- According to Edwards, what is true Christian zeal, and against what is it chiefly directed? (about 1:59:50)
- What parable does Edwards use to show that a forgiving spirit is absolutely necessary? What does it teach? (about 2:03:00)
- What did Edwards mean by saying "we must learn the way of bringing men to rules, and not rules to men"? (about 2:14:05)
- ★ Ninth sign: what do gracious affections do to the heart, and what are they attended with? (about 2:16:55)
- How do false affections affect a person's heart over time, especially after he becomes confident that he is saved? (about 2:17:10)
- Ninth sign: some trust Christ as the Savior OF their sins rather than FROM sin. What does Edwards mean? (about 2:19:25)
- To whom does Edwards compare the tenderness of a true Christian? Give a supporting verse. (about 2:20:20)
- Does assurance of salvation take away all fear for a true saint? Explain which fear it removes and which fear it increases, and give a supporting verse. (about 2:24:35)
- Is there such a thing as holy boldness in prayer? How is it related to reverence? Give at least one Bible example Edwards uses. (about 2:27:05)
- Explain Edwards' contrast between a burnt child and iron that is heated and suddenly quenched. (about 2:33:35)
- ★ Tenth sign: what does Edwards say distinguishes truly holy affections from false ones in their overall shape or balance? (about 2:36:45)
- Give at least three examples of the lopsided (disproportioned) religion of hypocrites that Edwards describes. (about 2:37:15)
- Why do true saints have this balance of graces while hypocrites do not? (about 2:37:40)
- Tenth sign: what does Edwards mean when he compares hypocrites to Ephraim, "a cake not turned" (Hosea 7:8)? (about 2:39:15)
- What general rule did Edwards give about people who claim high attainments in religion but have never reached the lower ones? Give one of his examples. (about 2:49:35)
- Using Edwards' pictures, how does a true saint's steadiness over time differ from a hypocrite's? (Think of a brook after a rain shower versus a living spring, or comets versus fixed stars.) (about 2:56:45)
- How does true religion behave when a person is alone, compared with when he is in company? Name at least three people in Scripture to whom God gave great favors when they were alone. (about 2:59:10)
- ★ Eleventh sign: what happens to a true saint's spiritual appetite as his gracious affections rise higher? How are false affections different? (about 3:05:40)
- Give a verse about craving spiritual growth or pressing on toward the goal. (about 3:07:20)
- Eleventh sign: if spiritual enjoyments are "soul-satisfying," why do saints keep longing for more? Give at least two of the ways Edwards says they satisfy. (about 3:10:40)
- How does a hypocrite's attitude after a high religious experience differ from a true saint's? What does each one long for? (about 3:12:10)
- To whom are most of the New Testament's commands to watch, strive, wrestle, run the race, and press forward directed: to sinners seeking conversion, or to saints? (about 3:17:45)
- ★ Twelfth sign: in what do gracious and holy affections have their exercise and fruit? (about 3:22:35)
- Name the three things Edwards says this twelfth sign includes. (about 3:23:00)
- What does Edwards mean by universal obedience? What does keeping and excusing even one sin show about a person's heart? Give a supporting verse. (about 3:24:10)
- What does it mean to make religion the business of one's life rather than a side matter? Give a supporting verse. (about 3:29:05)
- Why is perseverance through trials such an important evidence of true grace? Give a supporting verse. (about 3:33:55)
- What do the knobs and flowers on the golden lampstand, and the golden bells and pomegranates on the high priest's robe, picture? (about 4:02:10)
- Twelfth sign: Pharaoh offered several compromises before letting Israel go. Name at least two, and explain what they picture in a sinner who will not part with all his sins. (about 4:10:15)
- ★ Edwards calls Christian practice the chief of all the signs of grace. The chief sign to whom? (about 4:15:20)
- As a sign to others, why does Edwards rank a person's practice above his talk about his experiences? Give the verse Edwards relies on. (about 4:16:25)
- Does Edwards require new converts to give an account of the exact steps of their conversion before they are accepted as Christians? Explain. (about 4:21:45)
- Besides believing the doctrines of the gospel, what else must a true profession of Christianity include? (about 4:31:00)
- Is it strong evidence of grace that a person is simply an "honest, moral man" with nothing to charge against him? Explain. (about 4:48:10)
- As a sign to one's own conscience, does Edwards mean only outward acts? What else does he include? (about 5:00:05)
- What two kinds of exercises (acts) of grace did Edwards describe? (about 5:02:45)
- Why does Scripture call life's difficulties "trials"? What did God say to Abraham after he offered Isaac? Give the reference and quote it. (about 5:23:50)
- Edwards uses several pictures for how trials prove what is real. Name at least two. (about 5:24:20)
- What does it mean that faith is "made perfect" (completed) by works? Give the verse and explain Edwards' picture of a tree. (about 5:33:00)
- What evidence will Christ use at the Day of Judgment? Will He ask each person to tell the story of his conversion? Give a supporting verse. (about 5:54:10)
- How does Edwards explain "trusting" Christ? Explain his picture of the man told he would be heir to the king of a distant island. (about 6:12:00)
- Edwards says the trial of a good soldier is not in his "chimney corner." What does he mean, and what grace is he speaking of? (about 6:18:50)
- Is Christian practice a different thing from Christian experience? What does Edwards mean by "experimental religion"? (about 6:23:45)
- When does Christ commonly give His saints the greatest and most joyful evidence that they are His children? Give a Bible example Edwards uses. (about 6:32:05)
- Does making Christian practice the chief sign of grace teach salvation by works? Explain. (about 6:34:55)
- Answering the objection that this teaching is "legal," explain Edwards' illustration of the beggar and the money in his hand. (about 6:35:30)
- Give one place in Scripture where God's free invitation of grace and the necessity of a holy life are taught together. (about 6:37:35)
- Name at least three good results Edwards says would follow if Christians judged themselves chiefly by their practice. (about 6:51:45)
- With what verse does Edwards close the treatise? What is his point about how Christians should show their religion? (about 6:54:00)
Self-examination (for reflection and prayer):
- When I am humbled over my sin, is it mainly because I fear punishment (legal), or because I see God's holiness and my own unworthiness (evangelical)?
- Has my nature truly changed - especially regarding the sins I was most inclined to before?
- Am I gentle, meek, and forgiving like Christ, or harsh, bitter, and quick to anger?
- Is there any one sin I keep and excuse? What would it take to give it up?
- Do I long for more holiness, or have I settled into being satisfied with where I am?
- Would the people who know me best - at home and at work - see the fruit of Christ in how I live?
Show answer key
- ★ Evangelical humiliation.
- Evangelical humiliation is a sense that a Christian has of his own utter insufficiency, despicableness, and odiousness, with an answerable (matching) frame of heart.
- (1) Who: legal humiliation can be found in people still in a state of nature (unconverted); evangelical humiliation belongs only to true saints. (2) Source: legal humiliation comes from the common influences of the Spirit assisting natural principles, especially natural conscience; evangelical humiliation comes from the special, saving influences of the Spirit implanting and exercising new, supernatural principles.
- Legal: they see God's great and terrible majesty and their own sin and danger of punishment. Evangelical: they see the transcendent beauty of God's holiness and moral excellence, and their own vileness in comparison.
- It brings the heart to renounce and deny itself - to freely and willingly lie in the dust before God, giving up all self-exaltation and self-righteousness. Legal humiliation may convince a person that he is helpless, but it does not bend his heart or make him willing to abase himself.
- They are brought sweetly to yield, and freely and with delight lie down at the feet of God. They voluntarily deny and renounce themselves, rather than being subdued against their will.
- It can be a means that leads toward evangelical humiliation, just as common knowledge of religion is a means toward spiritual knowledge. But in itself it has no spiritual good and nothing of true virtue: the wicked at the Day of Judgment will be legally humbled (fully convinced of their guilt and helplessness) without any true humility.
- Any one: "God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble" (James 4:6, BSB); "The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit; a broken and contrite heart, O God, You will not despise" (Psalm 51:17, BSB); or Isaiah 57:15 (God dwells with the contrite and lowly in spirit).
- (1) Denying one's worldly inclinations - forsaking worldly pleasures and objects. (2) Denying one's natural self-exaltation - renouncing one's own dignity, glory, and righteousness. The second is the harder and is the heart of evangelical humiliation. Hypocrites may seem to do the first (giving up some worldly things) while remaining full of the second (pride and self-righteousness).
- They "sold one lust to feed another" - they sold a beastly lust to pamper a devilish one (pride) and were never the better. They turned out one black devil to let in seven white ones that were worse than the first, though fairer looking.
- Any two: thinking highly of one's own experiences, attainments, or humility; loving to be noticed and to talk about one's own spiritual experiences; being quick to censure others and treat them as carnal or unconverted; being forward to teach rather than willing to learn; a bold, self-confident, assuming manner in religion.
- They use strong expressions about themselves ("I am the least of all saints," "I am a poor vile creature," "my heart is worse than the devil"), but say them lightly, sometimes with smiles, without a broken heart. Yet if a minister privately told them he feared they were very low and weak Christians, they would take it as a great injury and might become prejudiced against that minister.
- A legal spirit is a spirit of pride in one's own righteousness, morality, holiness, affections, experiences, faith, humiliation, or any goodness of one's own. A person who is proud of his experiences trusts in them and makes a righteousness of them, so he lives on his own righteousness even while he speaks against legalism.
- The truly humble saint thinks his humility is small and his pride great; he sees himself as among the least of the saints and is quick to see his own defects. The hypocrite is proud of his humility, thinks himself eminent in grace, and is quick to see the defects of others.
- (1) He is apt to think highly of his own attainments in religion compared with others - that he is an eminent saint - and is forward to take the highest seat, to teach, direct, and manage others. (2) He is apt to think highly of his own humility.
- "Do nothing out of selfish ambition or empty pride, but in humility consider others more important than yourselves" (Philippians 2:3, BSB).
- Because grace opens his eyes to the infinite reason he has to love and honor God, so his love and holiness look very small compared with what they ought to be. Like a hungry man who counts the food set before him a small matter compared with his appetite (or a prince's son who thinks the honor shown his father small compared with what his father deserves).
- Our obligation to love a being is in proportion to how lovely and worthy he is. God is infinitely lovely, so the least sin against Him has infinite hatefulness. But a creature's holiness has no infinite worth - the lower the creature, the less his respect is worth - so the highest holiness of a creature is less than a drop compared with the ocean.
- False discoveries tend to hide and cover a person's corruption, making it seem that all his sin is gone; that is darkness, not light. True spiritual light (especially a sight of God's holiness) searches sin out in its secret corners and makes it plain.
- Agur said he was more brutish (ignorant) than any man and had not the understanding of a man or the knowledge of the Holy One (Proverbs 30:2-3). New Testament: "The one who thinks he knows anything does not yet know as he ought to know" (1 Corinthians 8:2) - true spiritual knowledge makes a person more aware of his ignorance.
- (1) David wrote under immediate inspiration; the Spirit may reveal things to a prophet for the good of the church, so this proves nothing about the ordinary tendency of grace (just as David's inspired curses do not show that grace inclines men to curse). (2) The knowledge David spoke of may not have been saving spiritual knowledge but the greater revelation God gave him of the Messiah and His kingdom.
- People measure their humility from the height of dignity at which they think they stand. A great man washing another's feet would be noticed as humble, but no one would call a slave humble for untying a prince's shoes - and if the slave boasted of it, everyone would see he thought himself someone great. So the person who admires his own humility shows that he secretly has a high opinion of himself.
- Because he judges his conviction by comparing his sense of sin with the cause he has for it. He sees himself as one of the greatest of sinners, so it seems so plain to him that it could be seen without much conviction. Anyone who thinks his conviction is great in proportion to his sin really thinks his sins are small.
- No - true humility is not noisy, loud, or showy, and does not display itself in odd dress or ways of living. Any one: Ahab, when humbled, "went softly" (1 Kings 21:27); the penitent "sits alone and keeps silent" (Lamentations 3:28); "put your hand over your mouth" (Proverbs 30:32); when you fast, anoint your head and wash your face (Matthew 6:17).
- Whether, on that very account - because he thinks so meanly of himself - he secretly thinks himself very humble and better than others. Self-conceit can rise up under that very cover.
- Any three: he asks humbly rather than answering roughly (Proverbs 18:23); he is not quick to resent; he yields to others; he is patient with hard things and with being overlooked or despised; he takes reproof quietly; he readily honors others; he is easily taught; he is modest; he remains like a beggar at God's gates, empty and needy.
- Any two: Abraham stood up and bowed to the people of the land, the Hittites (Genesis 23:7); Paul called the governor "most excellent Festus" (Acts 26:25); Jacob bowed to the ground seven times before his persecuting brother Esau (Genesis 33:3). Also: "Honor everyone" (1 Peter 2:17).
- Just as the ointment could not flow out and fill the house with its fragrance until the box was broken, so gracious affections flow out to Christ from a broken heart. True Christian love, hope, desire, and joy are humble and broken-hearted.
- ★ A change of nature.
- "And we, who with unveiled faces all reflect the glory of the Lord, are being transformed into His image with intensifying glory, which comes from the Lord, who is the Spirit" (2 Corinthians 3:18, BSB). Only the power of the Creator can change a person's nature.
- "Therefore if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old has passed away. Behold, the new has come!" (2 Corinthians 5:17, BSB).
- They wear off and the person returns to his old ways, showing that no saving change was made. Bible picture: "A dog returns to its vomit," and, "A sow that is washed goes back to her wallowing in the mud" (2 Peter 2:22, BSB).
- A swine with a filthy nature may be washed, but its swinish nature remains; a dove with a clean nature may be soiled, but its clean nature remains. Nature is an abiding thing, so a change that does not last was never a change of nature.
- No - sin and natural temper remain in this life, and grace does not wholly root them out. But true conversion makes a great and lasting change, especially in the sins the person was most inclined to before (for example, a man inclined to lust, drunkenness, or malice will be especially changed in respect of those sins).
- Saul destroyed the lesser Amalekites but spared their king, and it proved his ruin. A person who forsakes other sins but spares his leading sin - the one he is most inclined to - is like Saul. True repentance turns a man especially against his own chief sins.
- Grace is not given like light passing through a glass, which stays unchanged and has no light of its own. God gives His Spirit to dwell in the soul as a new, abiding nature, so the saint himself becomes, as it were, a little sun shining with light from the Sun of Righteousness - like the tabernacle lamps that became burning, shining things - or a spring of living water within (John 4:14). So true grace leaves a lasting change.
- ★ The spirit of love, meekness, quietness, forgiveness, and mercy, as it appeared in Christ.
- The lamb and the dove. Christ is the Lamb of God, and the Holy Spirit descended on Him like a dove - both pictures of meekness, gentleness, and harmlessness, which is the true Christian spirit.
- "Take My yoke upon you and learn from Me; for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls" (Matthew 11:29, BSB).
- Any three: harmless and not dangerous; their anger does not last long and they do not hold grudges; not deceitful but plain and simple; yielding and flexible, not stubborn; they do not trust their own understanding but rely on their parents' instruction.
- Chiefly in ruling one's own spirit - restraining and subduing one's own sinful passions - not in fierceness or violence against others. Supporting verse: Proverbs 16:32 (the one who is slow to anger and rules his own spirit is greater than a mighty warrior who captures a city).
- From love and humility - a willingness to bear reproach and be thought a fool for Christ - not from pride. True boldness for Christ is gentle toward people even while it is firm for the truth; bitter, fierce zeal comes from pride and hurts others.
- Not with fiery passions or fierce speeches, but by not opening His mouth, going like a lamb to the slaughter, and praying for His enemies; not by shedding others' blood but by shedding His own with patience and love. When Peter struck with his sword, Christ meekly rebuked him and healed the wound.
- Being willing to be despised and thought least worthy by those of his own party, forsaking all and offending all rather than offend Christ, and confessing his own fault openly when he has committed one.
- It is the heat and fervor of the sweet flame of divine love. Its opposition is against evil things, not against persons; it is directed first and chiefly against the sins in the person's own heart, and secondarily against the sins of others.
- The parable of the servant who was forgiven ten thousand talents but would not forgive his fellow servant a hundred denarii, and was handed over to the jailers (Matthew 18:23-35). It teaches that if we do not forgive others from the heart, our heavenly Father will not forgive us (also Matthew 6:14-15).
- We must measure ourselves and others by God's Word as it stands, not stretch and bend the Bible's rules to fit ourselves and our neighbors until they mean nothing. Scripture knows of no true Christian who is sordid, selfish, cross, spiteful, or contentious.
- ★ They soften the heart, and they are attended with Christian tenderness of spirit (a tender conscience).
- False affections harden the heart over time. After such people become confident they are saved, they grow less fearful of sin, more presumptuous and careless, cast off fear and caution, and may neglect duties, as though their assurance gave them liberty.
- False affections can make people trust in Christ to protect them from God's anger while they keep their sins in peace - using Christ as a shield for sin instead of a Savior from it, as though He were a minister of sin (like those in Jude 4 who turned God's grace into a license for immorality).
- To a little child - tender, quick to feel sin, fearful of offending, and ready to be taught. "Truly I tell you, unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven" (Matthew 18:3, BSB).
- No. Assurance removes the servile, tormenting fear of hell and of God as an enemy, but it increases holy, reverent fear of God and fear of sinning against Him. "Continue to work out your salvation with fear and trembling" (Philippians 2:12, BSB).
- Yes, and it is found mostly in eminent saints, but it is never opposed to reverence: it removes the distance that comes from alienation, not the infinite distance between God and us. Any one example: Rebekah veiled herself when she met Isaac; Elijah wrapped his face in his mantle at the still small voice (1 Kings 19:12-13); Moses quickly bowed to the ground and worshiped (Exodus 34:8); the angels cover their faces before God's throne (Isaiah 6).
- A true penitent is like a burnt child that dreads the fire - tender and quick to fear sin. A person with a false conversion is like iron that is heated and suddenly quenched - it becomes much harder than before.
- ★ Truly holy affections have a beautiful symmetry and proportion - all the graces are present together and balanced.
- Any three: great joy and confidence but no holy fear; love to God but not love to neighbor; zeal against other people's sins but not his own; love to some Christians (his own group) but not to all; religious in public but not in secret; very earnest at times and then cold and careless; concern for the souls of strangers while neglecting his own family; talk of love for souls but no mercy or charity toward people's bodily needs.
- Because true grace is a whole new nature - the image of Christ - in which all the graces are given together. Hypocrites have only partial imitations of certain graces, so their religion is lopsided.
- Hypocrites' religion is lopsided - half done and half raw - with great affections in some areas and none in others, instead of the balanced whole image of Christ.
- If a person claims a higher attainment but has never reached the lower one, his claim is vain - like a traveler who thinks he has gone far beyond a place on the road he never reached. Any example: claiming to live a spiritual life beyond mere morality but not even being moral; claiming to be willing even to be damned for God's glory but unwilling to suffer a little loss of property or reputation for duty; claiming to trust God with his soul but not trusting Him enough to give a little money to godly and charitable uses.
- The hypocrite's religion comes in fits and starts - like a brook that runs only during and just after a rain shower, then dries up; or like comets that blaze for a while and then disappear (wandering stars, Jude 13). The true saint is like a stream from a living spring that keeps running even in drought, or a tree planted by the waters (Jeremiah 17:7-8), or like the fixed stars that shine steadily though sometimes clouded.
- True religion loves Christian fellowship but also delights in being alone with God in secret prayer and meditation; if a person is moved only in company and little in private, his religion "looks very darkly." Any three: Isaac meditating in the field when Rebekah came; Jacob alone when he wrestled and received the blessing; Moses at the burning bush and alone on the mountain 40 days; Elijah at Mount Horeb; Christ at the Transfiguration with only three disciples; Mary when the angel came to her; Mary Magdalene alone at the tomb; John alone on the island of Patmos.
- ★ The higher gracious affections rise, the more a spiritual appetite and longing after greater holiness and spiritual attainments increases. False affections rest satisfied in themselves.
- Any one: "Like newborn babies, crave pure spiritual milk, so that by it you may grow up in your salvation" (1 Peter 2:2, BSB); "I press on toward the goal to win the prize of God's heavenly calling in Christ Jesus" (Philippians 3:14, BSB).
- They satisfy, not in the sense that a person who has a little wants no more, but in these ways (any two): (1) they fully suit the soul, so it wants no other kind of happiness; (2) they fully answer the soul's expectation, unlike worldly pleasures; (3) their pleasure lasts, while worldly pleasures glut the appetite and leave it empty; (4) there is enough in them - an infinite ocean - to satisfy in degree. So the more the saint tastes, the more he longs for them.
- The hypocrite feels he has arrived and rests satisfied; his longing is mainly for comforts and remarkable experiences. The true saint is more aware of how far short he falls; he mourns his lack and longs above all for more holiness and more of God.
- Mostly to saints - Edwards says such words are spoken of the saints' work ten times for every once they are applied to sinners seeking conversion. Christians are not to have all their striving before conversion and then sit back in ease.
- ★ In Christian practice.
- (1) That one's behavior is universally conformed to and directed by Christian rules. (2) That one makes this holy practice the chief business of his life. (3) That one persists in it to the end of life, through all trials.
- Obeying all of God's commands, not just some. Keeping and excusing even one known sin shows that the heart is not truly given to God (like Herod, who heard John gladly and did many things, but would not give up Herodias - Mark 6:20). "You are My friends if you do what I command you" (John 15:14, BSB).
- It means being earnest, diligent, and devoted in serving God as one's main concern, not something done half-heartedly or only when convenient. "But seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness, and all these things will be added unto you" (Matthew 6:33, BSB).
- Because trials prove sincerity: God tests professors with difficulties, and only true grace endures (unlike the rocky ground, where faith withers when trouble comes). "But the one who perseveres to the end will be saved" (Matthew 24:13, BSB).
- The flower (profession) and the fruit (holy practice) always go together: wherever there was a flower there was a knob (apple or pomegranate), and wherever there was a golden bell there was a pomegranate. In true saints, a fair profession is always joined with real fruit in life - and that is how they shine as lights in the world (Matthew 5:15-16).
- Any two: "Go, sacrifice to your God within this land" (serve God but stay in Egypt - Exodus 8:25); do not go very far away; let only the men go and leave the women and children (Exodus 10:8-11); leave the flocks and herds behind (Exodus 10:24). They picture sinners who want to serve God and keep their lusts too, who give up some sins but not all - but not a hoof is to be left behind. And Pharaoh soon pursued Israel again, because his lusts were only restrained, not put to death.
- ★ Both to others and to one's own conscience.
- Because actions speak louder than words - a person's walk shows his heart more truly than his talk about his experiences, which hypocrites can imitate. Christ said: "So then, by their fruit you will recognize them" (Matthew 7:20, BSB).
- No. A profession of the essential things of Christianity is required, made with understanding and sincerity, but there is no trace in Scripture - "from Adam to the death of the Apostle John" - of requiring an account of the particular steps and method by which the Spirit worked. Such an account may help in some cases (as in ordaining a minister), but insisting on it as a requirement is unscriptural.
- Repentance of sin; a conviction of one's own sinfulness and of deserving God's wrath; a heart that renounces all sin; embracing Christ with the whole heart as one's only Savior; loving Him above all; being willing to forsake all for Him; and giving oneself to be entirely and forever His.
- No. Having nothing scandalous to charge against a person is not "letting his light shine." Strong evidence is positive holiness: a life that follows Christ's example, keeps the commands of both tables of the law, loves saints and enemies, is merciful and charitable, and walks as a Christian in every place and season - at church, at home, among neighbors, in business.
- No. He includes the inward acts of the soul that direct and go along with practice - especially the holy choices a person makes in times of trial, when he must choose between Christ and sin, and chooses Christ.
- (1) "Immanent" acts that begin and end within the soul, as in contemplation. (2) Practical or effective acts, in which grace in the will directs outward actions - for example, giving a cup of cold water to a disciple out of love, or willingly enduring persecution out of love to Christ.
- Because difficulties put it to the test whether a person will actually choose God over other things, proving whether he is what he professes to be. "...for now I know that you fear God, since you have not withheld your only son from Me" (Genesis 22:12, BSB). God tried Abraham not for His own information but to give Abraham clear evidence of his own sincerity.
- Any two: gold tested in the furnace; a building tested when the wind blows; wheat tested by winnowing (to see if it is only chaff); a staff tested by leaning on it; weighing ourselves in God's scales, with Christ in one and the world in the other.
- "You see that his faith was working with his actions, and his faith was perfected by what he did" (James 2:22, BSB). As a tree is not "perfected" when it is planted, sprouts, leafs out, or blossoms, but when it bears ripe fruit, so grace reaches its goal and completion in holy practice.
- Men's works - what they have done in this life. He will not examine the method of each person's experiences or ask each one to tell how he was converted. "And the dead were judged according to their deeds, as recorded in the books" (Revelation 20:12, BSB); also Ecclesiastes 12:14 and 2 Corinthians 5:10.
- To trust is to venture something, relying on another's sufficiency and faithfulness - to do something you would not do except for that dependence. If a man told he would be heir to a distant king leaves his land and all he has to go there, he has truly ventured himself on the promise; if he only sits still and enjoys the thought, he has ventured nothing. So true trust in Christ forsakes all, as far as called, in dependence on His promises (as Abraham, Moses, and Paul did: "I know whom I have believed" - 2 Timothy 1:12).
- Christian fortitude (courage and strength). A soldier proves himself on the field of battle, not by sitting at home by the fire, and so a Christian's fortitude is proved in actual practice under trial (1 Corinthians 9:25-26; 2 Timothy 2:3).
- No. All Christian practice (rightly understood, including the soul's choices) is Christian experience - and the most important and distinguishing part of it. Just as "experimental philosophy" brings ideas to the test of fact, "experimental religion" brings our religious affections and intentions to the test of actual trial. Experience without practice is worse than nothing.
- In their effectual exercises of grace under trials and sufferings - as seen in the full assurance and unspeakable joy of many martyrs (1 Peter 4:14; Romans 5:2-3). Bible example: Christ appeared with Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego in the fiery furnace.
- No. Practice is the evidence of grace, not the ground of our justification - we are justified by faith alone in Christ. But true faith always produces holy works that show it is real: "Show me your faith without deeds, and I will show you my faith by my deeds" (James 2:18, BSB).
- A beggar looking at the money in his hand as a SIGN of the giver's kindness does nothing to take away the freeness of the gift; it would only be against free grace if he held the money as the PRICE of the gift. So holy works are a sign of grace, never the price of God's favor. We are justified only by Christ's righteousness, received by faith.
- Any one: Isaiah 55:1 ("Come, buy... without money") with verse 7 ("Let the wicked man forsake his own way..."); Matthew 11:28 ("Come to Me, all you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest") with verse 29 ("Take My yoke upon you and learn from Me"); Revelation 22:14-17; Revelation 3:20-21; Isaiah 1:16-18; Proverbs 9:4-6.
- Any three: it would convince deluded hypocrites; it would free people from confusing schemes about the steps of conversion; it would promote strictness and earnestness of life; it would make it the fashion to show Christianity by behavior rather than by declaring one's experiences, with tongues going behind hands and feet; it would cut off occasions of spiritual pride and shut a door against the devil; it would convince unbelievers that religion is real, so they would glorify God (Matthew 5:16).
- "In the same way, let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in heaven" (Matthew 5:16, BSB). Christians should show their religion more by being lively in the service of God and their generation than by proclaiming their own experiences with their tongues.
Test: "A Treatise on Earthly Mindedness" by Jeremiah Burroughs (03h:33m:01s)
Watch the video (opens in a new tab)
- The preface ('To the Reader') opens with a saying: 'Every day a Christian spends on earth is a day lost in heaven.' How did the preface say this saying was meant? (about 0:10)
- According to the preface, what is the 'end and scope' of these sermons, and what did it say about Burroughs himself? (about 1:45)
- What reason from 1 Corinthians 7:29-31 does the preface give for setting our hearts loose from earthly things? (about 2:35)
- What is the main text of the treatise, and what phrase in it does Burroughs open? (about 5:50)
- Burroughs says the word translated 'mind' can also be translated another way. What is it, and which part of the soul does he chiefly deal with? (about 6:45)
- Who were the men Paul described in Philippians 3:18-19, and what two kinds of them does Burroughs mention? (6:15 to 10:30)
- ★ What 'doctrinal truth' (the great difference between a wicked man and a godly man) does Burroughs draw from Philippians 3:19-20, and what parallel verse does he give? (about 8:30)
- ★ Name the five things Burroughs said he would handle about earthly-mindedness. (about 10:30)
- ★ Does having and using earthly things make a person earthly minded? Give the Scriptures Burroughs uses. (about 12:05)
- First mark: an earthly minded man looks on earthly things as the greatest things. How does Burroughs use the blessings of Jacob and Esau (Genesis 27) to illustrate this? (about 15:45)
- Second mark: the 'choice thoughts' of the heart. Why does Burroughs say thoughts reveal the heart better than words or actions, and what illustration does he use? (about 17:50)
- Which thoughts does Burroughs NOT count as proof of an earthly mind, and which thoughts DO reveal it? (about 20:00)
- Third mark: the heart 'cleaves' to the earth. What two illustrations does Burroughs use? (about 21:35)
- Fourth mark: distracting cares. What two things cause distracting cares, according to Burroughs? (about 23:50)
- How does a godly man differ from a worldly man when bad news comes about his earthly estate? Give Burroughs' illustration. (about 26:00)
- Fifth mark: the great business of the heart. What does Burroughs mean by an 'adequate object,' and how does a child's play illustrate it? (about 28:40)
- What saying of Tertullian about how Christians ate and drank does Burroughs quote, and what lesson does he draw? (about 30:50)
- Burroughs contrasts how a godly man uses the world with how an earthly man uses spiritual things. What is the contrast? (about 31:25)
- Sixth mark: seeking earthly things for their own sake. What should be the 'end' (aim) of a godly man in following his calling, according to Burroughs (with 2 Corinthians 4:18)? (about 33:05)
- Who does Burroughs say is more spiritual: a godly man cutting hedges, digging ditches or swinging a hammer, or an earthly man praying, hearing sermons or receiving the sacraments? (about 36:55)
- Eighth mark: what does Burroughs say about weariness and difficulty in earthly versus spiritual things? Include his fish illustration and Malachi 1:13. (about 38:00)
- What challenge about the Lord's Day (Sabbath) does Burroughs give his hearers, and what does a spiritual heart call the Sabbath? (about 40:30)
- Ninth mark: how does an earthly minded man understand the doctrine of justification (making peace with God)? (about 43:20)
- How does Burroughs use Isaiah 1:3 to show the difference between an earthly man's and a spiritual man's knowledge of God, and how does each understand heaven? (about 44:25)
- First evil of earthly-mindedness: what does Scripture call it? Give the verse. (about 49:10)
- ★ Second evil: what does Scripture call it, and how does Burroughs explain the First Commandment in connection with it? (about 50:25)
- Why does Burroughs say making an idol of earthly things is especially vile? Give his comparison with the Egyptians. (about 53:05)
- Burroughs names two things that make this idolatry evil. What are they, and which Scriptures does he use? (about 54:40)
- Third evil: enmity against God. Why were the earthly minded men in Philippi enemies of Paul's preaching? (about 57:55)
- Fourth evil: earthly-mindedness is contrary to the very beginning of the work of grace. What is the first work of grace in a soul, and what is Christ's first lesson to a disciple? (about 1:00:35)
- Burroughs names three things in conversion that earthly-mindedness is directly opposite to. What are they? (about 1:05:30)
- Burroughs describes grace in four ways that earthly-mindedness opposes. Name them, with his illustration for the first and the verse for the last. (about 1:08:05)
- How does Burroughs say a spiritual heart and an earthly heart differ when a matter of conscience arises in business? (about 1:11:55)
- Sixth evil: earthly-mindedness hinders profiting from the ministry of the word. How does Burroughs use Ezekiel 33:31 to show this? (about 1:12:45)
- In the parable of the sower, who are the thorny-ground hearers, according to Burroughs, and what chokes the word? Give the verse. (about 1:16:00)
- What examples does Burroughs give of people who lost the benefit of the word through the world - one from the Gospels and one from his own day? (about 1:19:10)
- Seventh evil: earthly-mindedness causes 'foolish lusts' (1 Timothy 6:9). Quote the verse and name at least three of the six follies Burroughs lists. (about 1:22:00)
- Explain the folly of being 'a servant to your servants.' (about 1:23:05)
- Burroughs says nobody who was diligent in seeking God ever 'miscarried.' How does he contrast this with earthly business, and what is his illustration of the voyage to the Indies? (about 1:28:50)
- Why does Burroughs insist that a man who has gained things by deceit or cheating must make restitution? (about 1:32:35)
- How does an earthly minded person 'lose the comfort of earthly things before they have them'? (about 1:35:20)
- ★ Eighth evil: earthly-mindedness is the root of apostasy. Whom does Burroughs use as the example? Quote the verse. (about 1:37:30)
- What small detail in Colossians 4:14 does Burroughs point out about Luke and Demas, and what does he say the 'breath' of a coming apostate smells like? (about 1:38:00)
- Ninth evil: earthly-mindedness deadens the heart in prayer and duties. What did David pray in Psalm 119:36-37, and why is an earthly heart a dead heart? (about 1:42:20)
- Tenth evil: what does Jeremiah 17:13 say about those who forsake the Lord, and what does verse 11 say about the man who gets riches unjustly? (about 1:46:10)
- Eleventh evil: whose curse does an earthly minded man bear, and how does it contrast with what the saints feed on? (about 1:48:45)
- Twelfth evil: how is earthly-mindedness a dishonor to God and a scandal to religion? Give at least two of Burroughs' comparisons. (about 1:49:55)
- Thirteenth evil: earthly-mindedness hinders preparation for death and affliction. What warning did Christ give His own disciples (Luke 21:34)? (about 1:54:20)
- What illustration does Burroughs use to show why affliction and death are so painful to an earthly heart? (about 1:56:45)
- What true story does Burroughs tell of a covetous man on his deathbed, and what does he say the Christian life should be? (about 1:59:20)
- Fourteenth evil: earthly-mindedness brings destruction at last. What illustration from bathers in the Thames does Burroughs use, and what does he say about the 'dunghill'? (about 2:02:00)
- ★ Burroughs says a person may be earthly minded and not know it. Name at least four of the five things that may be found in a person who is still earthly minded. (about 2:05:40)
- How does Burroughs use the Medes (Isaiah 13:17) to warn people who think they are above covetousness, and what is the RIGHT ground for being above earthly things? (about 2:09:30)
- Burroughs gives two quick tests before his nine proofs. What are they? (about 2:11:40)
- Proof 1: resting on earthly props. What does Burroughs say about trusting earthly helps, and what Scripture does he use? (about 2:13:50)
- Proof 2: making most provision for this world for oneself and one's children. What should a spiritual parent be most concerned about, and what example from church history does Burroughs give? (about 2:15:40)
- ★ Proof 3, which Burroughs calls very secret: what does an earthly minded man accept about the assurance of his soul, compared with his earthly affairs? (about 2:19:25)
- Proof 4: what standard does an earthly minded man compare himself to in worldly matters, and in matters of religion? (about 2:24:45)
- Proof 5: wise in the world, simple in religion. What test does Burroughs suggest for his hearers on the walk to London? (about 2:26:55)
- Proof 6: what do men's words reveal? Give the verse Burroughs uses and the times he says earthly talk is most out of place. (about 2:29:35)
- Proof 7: what happens to spiritual duties when earthly business presses, and what verse shows the opposite (a spiritual mind)? (about 2:32:15)
- Proof 8: how does Burroughs use Eli to test whether a heart is earthly? (about 2:33:55)
- Proof 9: the more spiritual a truth is, the less it moves an earthly man. What illustration about the stars does Burroughs use? (about 2:37:10)
- Name at least four of the seven reasons Burroughs gives for why men are earthly minded. (about 2:39:15)
- Burroughs says Scripture calls spiritual things the only real things and earthly riches 'that which is not.' What Scriptures does he use, and what example of empty pomp? (about 2:39:55)
- What does Burroughs mean when he says that 'wisdom is a lie to a fool,' and how does he say the earthly minded man's way will turn out (Psalm 49:13)? (about 2:41:00)
- Consideration 1 and 2 (of eleven): what does Burroughs say about the least sinful thought, and about whose portion the chief things of the earth have been? (about 2:50:35)
- Considerations 3 and 4: what does Burroughs say about God's thoughts toward mankind and about the dignity of the soul? Include his 'golden mill' illustration. (about 2:53:15)
- Consideration 5: the uncertainty of earthly things. What two Bible examples does Burroughs give, and why can it be a mercy when God crosses us in earthly things? (about 2:58:40)
- Considerations 6 and 7: what does Burroughs ask about men of former ages, and what illustration does he give for the shortness of time? (about 3:01:50)
- Consideration 8: 'a little will carry us through this world.' What illustration and verse does Burroughs use? (about 3:05:35)
- Consideration 9: what does Burroughs say earthly things are, and how does Psalm 62:10-11 support it? (about 3:07:35)
- Consideration 10: why does Burroughs say a godly person has less excuse for anxious earthly care than an orphan? (about 3:10:15)
- Consideration 11: professors of religion are dead to the world. Quote Colossians 3:2-3 and explain Luther's observation about Abraham's seed being like the stars and the sand. (about 3:13:30)
- Someone asks, 'May we not mind earthly things and heavenly things too?' and 'We need these things while we are on earth.' How does Burroughs answer? (about 3:16:50)
- What warning does Burroughs give young beginners in religion, using the picture of miners? (about 3:20:30)
- Why does Burroughs say earthly-mindedness is a worse sin in the time of the gospel than under the law? (about 3:23:50)
- ★ Name the five directions Burroughs gives for freeing the heart from earthly-mindedness. (about 3:25:30)
- Quote Hebrews 11:13 and explain how the example of the saints in Hebrews 11 should affect us. (about 3:27:40)
- Why does Burroughs say meditating on the DEATH of Christ (not only His glory) frees the heart from the world? Give the verse from Paul. (about 3:29:50)
- What story about a king of France does Burroughs use to close, and what is his final appeal? (about 3:32:00)
Self-examination (for reflection and prayer):
- Burroughs says you know your heart best by the thoughts that are sweet to you when you are alone. What do your thoughts run to most when you are free and alone?
- Which of the nine marks of an earthly mind (highest esteem, choice thoughts, cleaving, distracting cares, great business, seeking things for themselves, earthly in spiritual duties, never weary in worldly work, earthly view of heavenly truths) do you see most in yourself?
- Are you content with a slight, unexamined 'hope' about your soul while you work hard to make your earthly affairs secure? What evidence of saving grace can you actually point to?
- Is your prayer or Bible reading the first thing to 'pay' when your day gets busy? What would change if you sought God first each morning?
- Are you more troubled by losing money or by losing the sense of God's presence? More glad over a good bargain or over a truth God taught you from His word?
- If you died tonight, could you let go of earthly things as easily as loose clothes at bedtime, or would they tear away like a garment stuck to a sore? Why?
Show answer key
- It was meant of the PLACE, not the COMPANY. What makes heaven is union and communion with God in Jesus Christ, and that is attainable in this life, so a Christian can "live in heaven" (in fellowship with God) while he lives on earth (1 John 1:3; Philippians 3:20; Galatians 2:20).
- To wind up the reader's heart to a heavenly frame: to take it off perishing vanities and set it on what is real and lasting. Burroughs, though he had much of the comfort the earth could give, looked on all creature contentment "with the eyes of a stranger" and lived in heaven while on earth. The preface says the sermons were "twice printed": once in his practice (his life) and once on paper.
- The time is short (the remainder of our season is "folding up" like a curtain), so those who weep, rejoice, buy and use the world should do so as though they did not, without abusing the world. Time is short, life is shorter, and the end of all things is at hand.
- Philippians 3:19, "who mind earthly things" (with verse 20, "our citizenship is in heaven"). BSB: "Their end is destruction, their god is their belly, and their glory is in their shame. Their minds are set on earthly things. But our citizenship is in heaven, and we eagerly await a Savior from there, the Lord Jesus Christ" (Philippians 3:19-20, BSB).
- It can be translated "savor" or "relish" earthly things. The word covers both the understanding and the will, but he deals chiefly with the will and the affections.
- Enemies of the cross of Christ who opposed Paul's ministry and went from house to house to draw people away from the ways of God. Some were grossly sensual (their belly was their god: drunken, unclean). Others did not look so brutish, yet were earthly minded, and these are secret enemies of the cross of Christ; in time it breaks out.
- ★ The wicked man minds earthly things; the godly man has his citizenship (conversation) in heaven. Parallel: "Those who live according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh; but those who live according to the Spirit set their minds on the things of the Spirit" (Romans 8:5, BSB).
- ★ (1) What it is to mind earthly things in a sinful way; (2) the great evil of it; (3) proofs to convince those who think they are clear of it; (4) the reasons why hearts run after earthly things; (5) means to take the heart off earthly things.
- ★ No. Paul knew how to abound as well as to be in need (Philippians 4:12); Christ said our heavenly Father knows we need these things (Matthew 6:32); and Paul charged believers to share all good things with those who teach them (Galatians 6:6-7). The sin is minding them, not having them.
- Both were blessed with the dew of heaven and the fatness of the earth, but in Jacob's blessing the dew of heaven comes FIRST and the fatness of the earth second, while in Esau's the fatness of the earth comes first. Each blessing suited the man's disposition: a godly heart needs earthly things but minds heaven first; a carnal heart grants it needs heaven but desires the earth first.
- Thoughts are the immediate "bubbles" of the heart, its firstborn; words and actions can be kept in by outward respects. You judge a fountain's water best where it bubbles up at the fountainhead, not a mile down the stream. "As he thinketh in his heart, so is he" (Proverbs 23:7, KJV, as Burroughs quotes it).
- Not every evil thought injected by the devil or a passing wandering through weakness. What reveals the heart are the thoughts that are sweet to the soul, especially when a person is alone and free, the ones it can run on for two or three hours with delight.
- Samson's soul cleaving to Delilah (say what you will against her, his soul still cleaves to her), and the serpent's belly cleaving to the dust. Talk to such men of the vanity of earth or the excellence of heaven; they will hear you, but their souls still cleave to the earth.
- (1) Viewing disappointment (losing the thing) as a very great, intolerable evil - "I would be undone"; and (2) uncertainty in the means of preventing that disappointment - seeing nothing certain to rely on (and not daring to trust a promise of Scripture).
- A worldly man is like a merchant who sent his whole estate abroad in one venture: if bad news comes, he is undone. A godly man is like a man with a large stock at home to live on: he has treasure in heaven, so losing earthly things does not undo him. He also has a certain promise to rest on: God will never leave him nor forsake him (Hebrews 13:5), and he may cast all his care on Him (1 Peter 5:7).
- An adequate object is something worth laying out the whole strength of the soul upon. A child's game is adequate to a child, so he gives it all his strength; a parent may play along, but the game cannot fill the parent's soul. Earthly business should be like that to a spiritual man: he does it, but it is not adequate to his heart - he reserves his chief strength for higher things.
- Christians ate and drank so as remembering that they were to pray that night before they slept. So a spiritual heart follows its outward business but remembers it must converse with God that night, and so reserves the strength of its spirit for communion with God.
- The godly man uses the world as if he used it not (his heart is not in it). The earthly man uses spiritual things as if he used them not: he hears as if he heard not and prays as if he prayed not - his heart is not there. He is like Korah, Dathan and Abiram: the earth opens and swallows up his heart.
- To show his obedience to God and to provide things that may help him serve God in his generation - earthly things sought in subordination to higher things. The earthly man follows his business "that he might get, that he might have more," and to satisfy the flesh. "So we fix our eyes not on what is seen, but on what is unseen. For what is seen is temporary, but what is unseen is eternal" (2 Corinthians 4:18, BSB).
- The godly man at his lowest work. A spiritual man is spiritual even in earthly things, while an earthly man is earthly even in spiritual duties (his ends there are esteem, covering some evil, form, or quieting his conscience). It will be seen so at the day of judgment.
- An earthly man goes through great toil and difficulty for gain and is never weary, because he is in his element - as a fish is never weary of swimming. But in spiritual things every molehill is a mountain; rising early, reading and praying are "hard" and tedious. They say, like the people in Malachi, "Oh, what a nuisance!" (Malachi 1:13, BSB).
- Try to spend just one Sabbath wholly spiritually - rise early, pray alone, read, hear, meditate, talk over what you heard, catechize the family, pray again - and see how wearisome it is to a carnal heart. A spiritual heart calls the Sabbath a delight, a type and forerunner of the eternal rest in heaven.
- In an earthly way: he thinks he makes peace with God the way one man makes peace with another after a falling out - by something he must perform. Free justification by the grace of God in Christ is too spiritual and heavenly for him to grasp.
- "The ox knows its owner, and the donkey its master's manger" (Isaiah 1:3, BSB). The earthly man knows God only as the ox knows the one who brings its fodder - as the Giver of good things in this world. The spiritual man knows God as He is in Himself, as one man knows another. Likewise the earthly man imagines heaven as pleasure without pain and pompous glory; the spiritual man looks for communion with God and Christ.
- Spiritual adultery. "You adulteresses! Do you not know that friendship with the world is hostility toward God? Therefore, whoever chooses to be a friend of the world renders himself an enemy of God" (James 4:4, BSB). If our hearts go after anything more than Christ, our Husband, it is adultery.
- ★ Idolatry: covetousness is idolatry (Ephesians 5:5; Colossians 3:5). Whatever the heart is most set on is its god. "You shall have no other gods before Me" means: give Me, and nothing else, the strength of your soul as your highest good. To bow the soul to anything else is worse than bowing the knee.
- The baser the thing made a god, the viler the idolatry. Other heathen worshiped the sun, moon and stars, but the Egyptians worshiped dogs, cats and onions, so their idolatry was the vilest. The earth is the lowest, dullest, least beautiful element of creation, so to make it one's god is most vile.
- (1) You depart from God and go out from under His protection, goodness and mercy - they have "gone a whoring from under their God" (Hosea 4:12, KJV). (2) It shows contempt for God - like a man leaving a beautiful queen for a dunghill beggar woman. Jeremiah 2:12-13: "My people have committed two evils: They have forsaken Me, the fountain of living water, and they have dug their own cisterns - broken cisterns that cannot hold water" (BSB).
- Earthly-mindedness makes men enemies to whatever is spiritually good. They would have been content with Christ mixed with circumcision, but the spiritual preaching of Christ - justification by faith alone, Christianity in its purity - did not suit their carnal hearts. There are no greater enemies to the ministry of the word and the work of grace than earthly minded men.
- The first work of grace is to disengage the soul from the creature - to take it off the earth. Christ's first lesson: whoever would be His disciple must deny himself, take up his cross and follow Him. The converted soul says, "Let me have my sin pardoned, and farewell earth."
- (1) God's effectual CALLING of the soul out of the world ("your happiness is not here; one thing is necessary"); (2) the soul's answer: self-denial and taking up Christ's cross (the enemies of the cross are earthly minded); (3) the soul's RESIGNING itself up to God as its chief, soul-satisfying good forever.
- (1) Grace brings a new LIGHT - but earthliness darkens the soul, as the earth coming between us and the sun causes an eclipse; (2) grace makes a NEW CREATURE - the first man was of the earth, earthly, the second Man is the Lord from heaven; (3) grace is ELEVATING - it raises the heart above the world; (4) grace is ENLARGING - nothing earthly can satisfy it, for to God the nations are "like a drop in a bucket" (Isaiah 40:15, BSB).
- For a spiritual heart, even a mere doubt that something is a sin is enough to stop it ("let the business go; there may be a snare in it"). An earthly mind strains through many dreadful things without trouble and snares itself exceedingly to get or keep an estate.
- "So My people come to you as usual, sit before you, and hear your words; but they do not put them into practice. Although they express love with their mouths, their hearts pursue dishonest gain" (Ezekiel 33:31, BSB). People praise the sermon and the preacher, but their hearts run after their covetousness, so no good comes to them. He also compares them to Martha, "encumbered about many things," and to travelers whose eyes are full of dust.
- Not lewd men (drunkards, swearers), but people with earthly hearts - often without knowing it. "The seed sown among the thorns is the one who hears the word, but the worries of this life and the deceitfulness of wealth choke the word, and it becomes unfruitful" (Matthew 13:22, BSB). The word may affect them while they hear, but houses, gardens, income and full tables choke it before it sinks in.
- The rich young ruler, who had great possessions - his heart mixed with the earth kept him from embracing Christ. And some young men who were very forward and loved the word while they were servants, but when they got into the world and tasted its sweetness, the word was choked and they lost their relish for it.
- "Those who want to be rich, however, fall into temptation and become ensnared by many foolish and harmful desires that plunge them into ruin and destruction" (1 Timothy 6:9, BSB). The six follies: (1) spending the strength of an immortal soul on trifles (like catching flies or chasing feathers); (2) becoming a servant to your servants; (3) a man might have MORE of the earth if he minded it less; (4) paying far more than a thing is worth; (5) getting things that must be undone (restitution); (6) losing the comfort of earthly things before you have them.
- God made earthly things to be our servants, yet the earthly man puts his neck under their yoke and seeks all his honor from them - he is respected for his estate (his "servant"), not for any worth in himself. When such a man loses his estate, no one regards him. But a man with grace, even if as poor as Job, is honored by the angels of heaven.
- A man may be as diligent as possible in earthly business and still fail, but no soul at the judgment will be able to say, "Lord, I improved my talents to the uttermost to save my soul, and You denied me Your grace." Two men go to the Indies with the same money: one brings home precious stones that enrich his family; the other brings home baubles and is scorned. The world is a "sea fair" (market): we sail home loaded either with pearls or with things of no worth.
- Because a man cannot truly repent of a sin while he willfully continues in it, and as long as he keeps what is another's (when able to restore it), he goes on wronging him. All the sorrow and repentance in the world will not suffice without restitution if he is able. He cites Zacchaeus and warns deceitful servants who cheat their masters.
- By inordinate thoughts, cares and affections, they contract guilt before the thing comes. When God gives it, conscience asks, "Do I have this with God's blessing, or in His wrath?" The comfort is gone - it cost far more than it was worth. Had they waited on God's providence, they could have enjoyed God in it and blessed Him for it.
- ★ Demas. "Because Demas, in his love of this world, has deserted me and gone to Thessalonica" (2 Timothy 4:10, BSB). Demas had been a well-known professor of religion and a companion of Luke, but when Paul suffered, Demas thought there was no thriving in following a persecuted apostle.
- "Luke, the beloved physician, and Demas send you greetings" (Colossians 4:14, BSB) - Luke is called "beloved," but Demas is only named. Those close to such professors could already sense less spirituality in him. As a dying man's breath smells earthy, so before their great apostasy, professors' breath "smells of the earth" in their duties and conversation.
- "Turn my heart to Your testimonies and not to covetous gain... Turn my eyes away from worthless things; revive me with Your word" (Psalm 119:36-37, BSB). David knew his heart was dull in holy duties when his thoughts ran after earthly vanity. As the earth is the most sluggish, dead element, earthliness makes the heart dead and lifeless in spiritual duties; many prayers are spoiled by it.
- "All who turn away will be written in the dust, for they have abandoned the LORD, the fountain of living water" (Jeremiah 17:13, BSB) - earth shall be their portion. Verse 11: like a partridge that sits on eggs it did not lay (and does not hatch them), so is he who gets riches not by right; he will leave them in the midst of his days, and at his end he will be a fool.
- The curse of the serpent: "On your belly will you go, and dust you will eat" (Genesis 3:14, BSB). The earthly man grovels on the earth and feeds on dust, while the saints feed on Jesus Christ, the hidden manna, the bread from heaven.
- It clouds the excellence of grace, as mixing earth and dross with pure metal spoils it. Onlookers conclude religion is mere talk when professors are as worldly as anyone - like the spies who brought a bad report of Canaan. Even unbelievers with a generous spirit scorn the base, pinching sordidness of some professors; that disposition fits none but Judas, who carried the bag. Better to be cut short of the world than to scandalize the gospel.
- "But watch yourselves, or your hearts will be weighed down by dissipation, drunkenness, and the worries of life - and that day will spring upon you suddenly like a snare" (Luke 21:34, BSB). Christ warned even His disciples - not only of excess but of the cares of this life, which make that day come upon them unawares.
- A man in loose garments can easily put them off at bedtime, but if his inner garment sticks to a sore on his body, pulling it off causes great pain. Earthly things cleave to an earthly heart like that, so when affliction or death tears them away, it is grievous. Death is like a strainer: the good of earthly things runs out and the guilt (the dross) is left on the conscience.
- A covetous man near where Burroughs had lived called for his money bags as he was dying, hugged them and cried (swearing), "Must I leave you now?" By contrast, the Christian life should be a continual preparation for death, so that he can lay aside the world as easily as a man casts off loose clothes at bedtime; the grave is a bed where the saints fall asleep.
- Bathers wade in a little, then further and further, until they are over their heads and drown. So hearts slip by degrees into the world ("these things are lawful; I got them honestly") until they are drowned in destruction and perdition. Hell is like the common dunghill: not only carrion (gross sinners) is thrown there, but also the dust swept out of houses - respectable people with earthly hearts. Earthliness can damn as surely as adultery or murder.
- ★ (1) Being convinced that all things of this world are vanity; (2) having some contentment with his estate (even Esau said, "I already have plenty," Genesis 33:9, BSB); (3) speaking great words about the world's vanity; (4) being free from getting anything by deceit or injustice; (5) seeming to despise some earthly thing because of another ruling lust (the ambitious man despises money; the prodigal speaks against covetousness).
- The Medes, wicked heathen with no grace at all, "have no regard for silver and no desire for gold" (Isaiah 13:17, BSB). So disregarding money is not necessarily grace - it may be because another lust rules. A wicked man hates one sin only because it crosses another, not as sin against God. The right ground is the sight and experience of better things: "The Lord has shown me communion with Himself in Christ, and since then my heart has been above these things."
- (1) How you value yourself and others - do you value a poor godly man above a rich wicked man, and the least work of grace in yourself above all your estate? (2) Where your chief joy and sorrow lie - is the loss of God's face or of an estate what troubles you most; is profiting from the word or gaining from a bargain what gladdens you most?
- What a man most trusts in he makes his god; trust belongs to God alone. We may use outward means, but not trust them for the comfort of life: "If your riches increase, do not set your heart upon them" (Psalm 62:10, BSB). Trust in the living God for all outward things.
- That the children have instruction in the fear of God, an interest in Christ, and grace in their hearts - being unwilling to die before seeing some work of grace in them, rather than before leaving a full estate. Augustine's mother (Monica) wished to live chiefly to see her son converted; God granted it, and then she was willing to die.
- ★ He is content with slight assurance in the matters of heaven ("I hope I am converted; God is merciful") and cannot show any evidence of grace, yet in earthly matters he is never sure enough - he goes from lawyer to lawyer to make everything certain. On the sickbed such people can only say they "hope in God's mercy," with no ground to show. A gracious heart would not lose its assurance for a thousand worlds.
- In the world he looks at the highest of his rank or trade and is troubled until he reaches as high as they. In religion he looks at the lowest Christians and is content to be as low as they are, and it does not trouble him that others who started with no more than he have gone far beyond him in grace.
- On the walk they can run their thoughts on business the whole way - plotting, foreseeing objections and answering them. He challenges them to settle on one meditation about Christ while walking through the fields and see whether they can draw it out the whole way. Earthly men are wise in their generation but speak like children in saving knowledge.
- "They are of the world. That is why they speak from the world's perspective, and the world listens to them" (1 John 4:5, BSB). Their breath smells earthy. It is worst on the Lord's Day and right after hearing the word: instead of talking over what they heard, they talk of earthly matters and lose the truth before they get home.
- Prayer "must pay for it" - time is taken out of prayer, Bible reading and hearing; heaven must stand by until earth is served. The spiritual man seasons his heart with God first thing in the morning: "When I awake, I am still with You" (Psalm 139:18, BSB).
- Eli sat trembling, not for fear the Philistines would take his house, but for the Ark of God. An earthly man does not care how it goes with the church and the kingdom of Christ so long as his own "cabin" is safe. A spiritual heart asks, "Lord, what will become of Your great name, of religion, of the gospel?" more than "What will become of my estate?"
- From the earth, the stars look small and the earth looks vast, though the stars are far bigger; if we were in heaven, the heavenly bodies would look vast and the earth would scarcely be seen. So to earthly hearts, heavenly things (communion with God, living by faith on a bare promise, mortifying lusts, self-denial, the mysteries of the gospel) seem small, while fine stories or eloquence move them more.
- (1) Earthly things seem real to them, but spiritual things seem only a notion; (2) they think earthly things are necessary NOW and spiritual things only hereafter; (3) earthly things suit their nature (they are of the first Adam, who was of the earth); (4) earthly things make "a fair show in the flesh" (Galatians 6:12, KJV); (5) they never knew better things (like children born in a dungeon); (6) earthly principles are dropped into them by earthly company, who applaud them (Psalm 49:11-13); (7) their sensible experience of the sweetness of earthly things.
- Proverbs 23:5 (KJV: "Wilt thou set thine eyes upon that which is not?" speaking of riches) and Proverbs 8:21, where wisdom causes those who love her to inherit "substance" (KJV; that which truly is). Agrippa and Bernice came "with great pomp" - in the original, great "fancy" (show).
- To an earthly man, earthly things are real and the matters of religion are mere words and talk; he thinks everyone a fool who does not "grovel in the ground like a mole" with him. But "This is the fate of the foolish and their followers who endorse their sayings" (Psalm 49:13, BSB) - the "wise men of the earth" will prove the greatest fools in the end (Jeremiah 17:11).
- (1) If you possessed all the earth your heart is set on, there is not enough good in it to undo the evil of the least sin - even one sinful thought has more evil than all you will ever gain has good. (2) The chief things of the earth - even kingdoms and empires - have been, and are, the portion of reprobates whom God hates. Will a reprobate's portion ("dog meat") satisfy you?
- (3) God made man for higher things than food, drink and clothing: man alone on earth is capable of knowing and conversing with God; the Trinity consulted, "Let Us make man in Our image" (Genesis 1:26); Christ took man's nature and died for man. (4) The soul is a spirit of the same nature as angels - you would not use a golden mill to grind dirt and straw. The soul of the lowest galley slave or beggar is worth more than heaven and earth and all the riches of land and sea ("What will it profit a man if he gains the whole world, yet forfeits his soul?" Matthew 16:26, BSB).
- The rich fool who said, "You have plenty of good things laid up for many years. Take it easy," and that night heard, "You fool! This very night your life will be required of you" (Luke 12:19-20, BSB). And Nebuchadnezzar, boasting in his palace, was driven out to graze with the beasts. God often crosses men when their hearts are most glued to the earth, and that can be a great mercy - it shows them the vanity of their hearts; "it was a happy cross... much of Christ hung upon it."
- (6) What has become of those who had all the earth they desired, like Agrippa and Bernice? They acted their parts, left the stage, and all their vanity is buried with them; rich and poor go out the same way, and the wheel will soon bring us as low. (7) Time is short and our work great: a man who comes into the city for a business of great weight with little time does not stop to gaze at everything, but goes about his business. On our "little, short, uncertain inch of time" depend things worth more than ten thousand worlds.
- We are on a pilgrimage. A staff helps a traveler (Jacob crossed the Jordan with his staff), but a whole bundle of sticks on his shoulder only hinders him. "But if we have food and clothing, we will be content with these" (1 Timothy 6:8, BSB). Nature is content with little, and grace with less.
- Earthly things are only channels; there is no comfort in them except as God is pleased to let Himself out through them ("man shall not live by bread alone"). "If your riches increase, do not set your heart upon them" - because "God has spoken once; I have heard this twice: that power belongs to God" (Psalm 62:10-11, BSB). Power to do us good is in God, not in riches.
- An orphan with no father or friends seems to have some excuse to care for himself, but the saints have a heavenly Father who promises to provide (cast your care on Him; He clothes the lilies; the earth is the Lord's). Godliness has promises for this life as well as the next. Faith trusts God for the body as well as the soul, since both were redeemed by Christ's blood.
- "Set your minds on things above, not on earthly things. For you died, and your life is now hidden with Christ in God" (Colossians 3:2-3, BSB). Luther observed that God compared Abraham's seed both to the stars of heaven and to the sand of the seashore: some of his professed seed are heavenly minded (stars) and some earthly minded (sand). We should labor to be among the stars.
- No one can serve two masters (Matthew 6:24); Colossians 3:2 sets the two in opposition - a man cannot look up to heaven and down to earth at the same time. Christians live ON the earth but are not OF the earth, as Christ was on earth but from above: "The one who is from the earth belongs to the earth and speaks as one from the earth" (John 3:31, BSB). We need earthly things only in subordination to higher things - we live here only to provide for eternity and live to Christ's honor.
- Miners digging for gold are sometimes buried when the earth falls on them, or are choked by noxious vapors if no air shaft is left open. So while you dig in your calling, always keep a passage open to heaven for fresh gales of grace; if you spend a day in the world without some spiritual air from heaven, a choking vapor is coming.
- Under the law, God's promises came clothed in earthly expressions (gold, silver, the land of Canaan as a type of heaven). Now heavenly things are openly revealed: He who is from above has come among us, the heavens are opened, and their glory shines more brightly. Greater gospel light makes earthly-mindedness more sinful.
- ★ (1) Watch over your thoughts; keep them within scriptural bounds. (2) Be much humbled for sin - the weight of sin takes the heart off the earth. (3) Set the example of the saints before you, who confessed they were strangers and pilgrims. (4) Consider the account you must give for all earthly things. (5) Above all, set Jesus Christ before you and meditate on His death.
- "All these people died in faith, without having received the things they were promised. However, they saw them and welcomed them from afar. And they acknowledged that they were strangers and exiles on the earth" (Hebrews 11:13, BSB). They were stoned, sawn in two, wandered in sheepskins and goatskins, in deserts and caves - "of whom the world was not worthy" - and went joyfully through it. Their example should shame our earthly-mindedness.
- Christ, Lord of heaven and earth, put Himself in the lowest condition to redeem us; converse with His death deadens the heart to the world, and there is an excellence in being conformed even to His death. "I count all things as loss compared to the surpassing excellence of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord, for whom I have lost all things. I consider them rubbish, that I may gain Christ" (Philippians 3:8, BSB; see also 3:10).
- Asked about an eclipse, the king said he had so much business on the earth that he took little notice of the things of heaven. Burroughs pleads that this never be said of any of us - that our worldly business is so great we cannot inquire after Jesus Christ. The saints' business, trade, aims and bent are in heaven.
Have a question about a test, or want to talk through the self-examination questions? Please write through the Contact page.

